I remember hearing about Chris Squire's death in June of 2015. Rather unexpectedly, it hit me like a ton of bricks. No doubt my brother's death a couple months previously left me vulnerable, in a state of sadness and so Squire's passing was the second of a real 1-2 combo to the gut that left me reeling.
I remember hearing about this album's release in the summer of 2021. It had been seven years since its rather milquetoast predecessor had come out and I was beginning to wonder if Yes was done. Luckily they were not. At the time, if memory serves, the Covid lockdowns were winding down and life had taken on some semblances of normality. A new Yes album seemed like something of a treat for having survived not only Covid but the lockdowns too.
The album's cover was another doozy from Roger Dean. Rock formations as far as the eye can see with the title in something like Dwarvish runic script and the Yes logo rendered as a gorgeous bit of stained glass with a red bird inside. Looking at these fantastic covers, I have begun to miss listening to Yes albums on vinyl with the large renderings of the art and a sheet of lyrics & credits. Listening to Tales From Topographic Oceans was totally other than else. Opening the gatefold was like cracking open a grimoire with all those photos in Deanian frames adorning the mysterious lyrics and their arcane mumbo jumbo. And you got to see the whole painting.
I used to buy albums based on the artwork! I cannot recall the last time I did so.
So they had the album cover down. A good start. But I had questions on my mind. First, what would Billy Sherwood bring to the Yes sound beyond a bass tone? Second, would they be able to produce music that wasn't so tepid and uninspiring as most of the stuff on Heaven & Earth?
Sherwood was Squire's handpicked successor. He was family as he'd been involved with Yes or its members since the late 80s or early 90s. He helped out on Union, was second guitarist on the Talk tour, and mixed the Keys to the Ascension stuff. He was like a utility player for the Yes farm team who finally got called up to the majors when he became a fully-fledged member in the late 90s. That stint ended and it would not be until Heaven & Earth that we'd hear from him again as he did engineering and mixing duties for that album.
I didn't know what Yes with Sherwood on bass would sound like but at least I was comfortable with the guy filling Squire's shoes. It's not like he was some unproven schmo; he had proven himself already as being a more than capable player.
And so I wasn't worried about Sherwood like I was worried about this being another silver platter of mid-tempo bloat. Plus Davison was still something an of unknown quantity. I had no idea if he was responsible for the mess that is Heaven & Earth. Still, I took comfort that he was still in the band and hadn't been run out of town with brickbats. That he possessed a striking voice was proven; but could he contribute some good music to sing to? Could the band for that matter?
Shortly after The Quest was announced, "The Ice Bridge" was released as the first single. I think most prog fans had ELP's "Fanfare for the Common Man" come to mind with the first note or two. A drum fill and it's off to the races with a strong and steady beat. Yes! I mean, whew! Sherwood's bass was both rhythmic and melodic just like his friend's playing though the sound here was Sherwood's own. The lyrics had taken on even further shades of Jon Anderson with opaque lines such as "All eyes to the east, in a vision...Snowflower elder, he has walked forest green". I take the lyrics to be a call for humanity to stop shitting where we eat.
The final two and a half minutes or so feature Howe and Downes trading licks over a propulsive beat with Sherwood throwing a few tricks of his own in too. Howe's rapid fire notes cede to Downes' own machine gun bursts and around they go. This is just fantastic stuff! Another song that should still be in live setlists.
The excitement of the opener did not last as "Dare To Know" slows things down. The orchestration makes its first appearance here and it seems to come out of left field. On the plus side, it transitions out well. Not a great song but not bad. The harmony vocals are nice, Downes gets in some fine organ licks, and an acoustic guitar makes for a lovely outro. "Minus the Man" hears Davison teaming up with the new guy. It opens with Sherwood sliding down the neck of his bass and he does some fine bassy noodling here by which I mean he adds a lot of low end color instead of just keeping a beat. Lyrically it's about technology supplanting humanity and surely must contain one of the first prog mentions of AI. The strings seem to have driven out Downes on this one.
Coming in at just over 8 minutes and in 3 sections, "Leave Well Alone" is something of a mini-epic credited to Howe alone. The opening section is called "Across the Border" and, although it begins with a few lone plucks of a koto, the song eventually wends its way into a weird, proggy kind of strut. Lyrics such as "Taste the virtue of nothingness/Feel the motion from elsewhere" should disabuse anyone thinking that Jon Anderson was the source of all spacey, Zen-like lyrics for the band back in the day. The middle bit, "Not for Nothing", has a very faint R&B flavor to it while the final section, "Wheels", felt more than a bit like a slowed down "Würm" giving Howe a chance to solo the song to its denouement. Also, Sherwood's bass is loud here. I like it.
"The Western Edge" is about half as long as "Leave Well Alone" yet it too feels like a mini-epic. A slow opening comes replete with some solo Sherwood vocals as well as harmonizing. White picks up the pace and Howe's steel guitar soars as strings-like keys fill in the background. Sherwood is great here creating tension as the song seeks release. The big, soaring ending is warm and familiar, like the Yes of old.
"Future Memories" opens with Davison on acoustic guitar and he creates a slightly ethereal, moderately dark feel. Howe adds steel guitar flourishes. The sentiments of "Through all of life's complexities/I often miss the scenery" are perhaps, not so much dark as regretful, uncertain. No drums here but we are treated to some very nice harmony vocals. "Music To My Ears" follows and begins with some gentle piano and hushed guitar. The verses are achingly beautiful and the organ splooshes work well next to the descending sounds of the guitar.
The album proper concludes with "A Living Island", another triptych. An acoustic guitar fanfare yields to an intimate sounding piano that accompanies Davison. "A world gone mad, on the last plane out we flew/There's no one with whom l'd rather brave the storm than you" sounded like it could have been on Fly From Here. The song picks up a bit once White's drums enter and Downes goes on a great little excursion on his Hammond. In the middle we get a dose of wordless vocal harmonizing a la "South Side of the Sky". With the final few verses the meaning of the lyrics becomes clear: they're about the Covid lockdowns and Davison honors the folks who could not work from home: "Here's to the frontline saviors" as well celebrates our shared determination to weather the storm: "We're in this together, though together apart in isolation".
Starting with this album, Yes would include bonus tracks of songs that didn't make the final cut. Here we get a trio beginning with "Sister Sleeping Soul" which is the best of the bunch. Howe is on his Portuguese 12 string guitar while Sherwood plays some interesting bits underneath. Great vocal harmonies and plenty of tasteful synth work from Downes. Some more lovely wordless vocal harmonies close things out. And when I say lovely, I mean really, really lovely.
"Mystery Tour" is a quaint three and a half minute chronicle of the history of The Beatles. Some nice playing but a little too twee. "Damaged World" is another plea for humanity to get its act together. Unfortunately, Howe's voice is not able to carry the homily alone. Some nice playing by Howe and his trusty steel guitar gives a vaguely country flavor while Downes treats us once more to some nice solos, but the song is saccharine rather than sincere to my ears.
Yes' sophomore effort with Davison is quite an improvement over Heaven & Earth. They stopped sounding like Bread trying to be clever and produced a wonderful album that had energy. The band sounds frisky yet willing to be delicate when needed. The lyrics are a nice mix of those that are open and direct and those that require a hierophant to comprehend their meaning. Sherwood is a fine replacement for Squire. He plays in the dearly departed bassist's style but is not a slavish imitator. He lovingly adds little melodic runs as Squire did but they sound like Sherwood.
"The Ice Bridge" and "The Western Edge" both join the pantheon of latter day Yes songs that should be in their setlists today. Somewhere on this blog I opined that Jethro Tull had enough great post-throat problems material to assemble setlists that focus on this period rather than treading the waters of Aqualung and straining Ian Anderson's voice yet again. Yes certainly has enough great post-Jon Anderson material to quit playing Fragile and Close to the Edge in their entireties and we've still got a couple more albums to go.
I get why these bands rely so heavily on the songs of their heydays - people my age and older who ignore/dismiss newer material. But it also deprives me and people like me who enjoy the Benoît David and Jon Davison eras of the pleasures of songs like "Into the Storm" and this:





































