07 September, 2007

Oktoberfesting

It has been quite some time since I've written about bier. This is not to say that I haven't been drinking it, but rather that I've just not been writing about it. I hope to correct that here.

Firstly I want to herald the arrival last month of Madison Beer Review. It appears to be a group effort and the folks are doing a great job with reviews, commentary, and news. In fact, they are much better than I could ever hope to be so I highly recommend heading over there with some frequency. In addition, Robin Shepherd over at Isthmus has begun writing with some frequency about beer. It began as a look at The Great Taste of the Midwest and has developed into a weekly beer review. The Daily Page is now a must-stop for beer aficionados.

As both Shepherd and the crew at MBR have noted, autumn nears and that means Oktoberfests!



I love autumn. I love the changing colors, the harvest bounty, and I love Capital's line-up. Beginning in September, I eagerly await each of their seasonals and limited editions through the spring. As I lamented last weekend, I was unable to attend Firefest at the Capital Brewery or, rather, I opted not to since I was on-call and couldn't drink. Had I been there, I would have witnessed the tapping of the season's inaugural keg of Autumnal Fire, brewmaster Kirby Nelson's fall limited release. It's a doppelbock that warms the palate and is the perfect beer to chase autumn's chill away. I look forward to this stuff just as I do to the leaves changing color. Capital's Oktoberfest is also available. This is another great beer and the pair yet again inspire me to thank Nelson for keeping lagers at the center of his brewery. There's no IPAs or race to the top of the IBU scale. I realize that Island Wheat is an ale and their most popular beer but, while refreshing on a hot day, I find it dull and uninspiring. It's more of a beer for hipsters to be seen drinking than anything else.



Over at my neighborhood brewery, the Ale Asylum, there's Diablo, a Beligan Dubbel as the fall seasonal. I turn from praising Capital for its lagers and praise AA for its line-up of Belgian style brews. Being able to head over there and grab a snifter of one of them is a real treat because they are tasty.

Over at J.T. Whitney's, look for their Marzen (i.e – Oktoberfest) soon. Their webpage doesn't list it as being on-tap yet. Yet. Also, kudos to them for having three different sodas on tap: Root Beer, Cream Soda, and Orange Cream. If you're the designated driver, you can still drink something that's made on premises. And, it's never too early to get kids to appreciate hand crafted foods, even if it's just soda.



I am going to go out on a limb here and say that we can expect Fallen Apple once again from Furthermore. However, I have heard a rumor that a different beer will be introduced this fall. Let's hope we get both.



Ever since changing ownership, the Huber website has been under construction. Still, look for Berghoff Oktoberfest.



I am eagerly awaiting the opening of New Glarus' expansion where I can guzzle top notch brews in an Old World setting just like some of my ancestors did. Until then, we can take comfort in Staghorn Octoberfest. I was just over the age requirement when New Glarus opened and I took to their brews like a junkie to the needle. Staghorn quickly became one of my favorites, not only of the NG arsenal, but of any beer. It was the first fall seasonal that made me look forward to the season. Also note that this month is the last for availability of their Totally Naked.



I've waxed poetically over Tyranena and its beers several times here. Robin Shepherd reviewed it at The Daily Page a couple days ago.



Also available on a return visit is Hop Whore, an Imperial IPA. It's part of brewmaster Rob Larson's Brewers Gone Wild! series.



Moving up north to Chippewa Falls, the venerable Leinenkugel's weighs in with their Oktoberfest. Also noteworthy is this:



A Russian Imperial Stout is the latest in their Big Eddy series of true craft beers. I thought that the first in the series, an IPA, was magnificent and will definitely be keeping my eyes peeled for this.



The Viking Brewing Company is quickly becoming a favorite of mine for many reasons. Their year-round brews are mostly lagers and they tend to eschew the hops arms race with their rotating brews which change every month. And they even make bracket, although I am still searching for it here in Madison. To top things off, their 4-packs are ultra-portable. As you can see, this month brings a ruach bier und a Swedish-style Imperial stout. Living as I do on the east side, I can say that the Jenifer Street Market carries a goodly selection of Viking's products.



Let's start our look at Brew City brews with Sprecher who has a wonderful Oktoberfest.



Lakefront has two seasonal brews – an Oktoberfest and a pumpkin lager. I'm not a big fan of pumpkin-spice beers and can handle only one per session. Unfortunately, I can't say that I've had Lakefront's Oktoberfest but I now dedicate myself to changing this sorry state of affairs.



Up in La Crosse, the City Brewery has their Festbier, a Marzen style brew. And they also appear to have a new variety:



At the moment, it appears to be available only on tap at locations in the west central part of the state and neighboring areas in Minnesota.



Moving over to Black River Falls and Sand Creek Brewing Company, we find Black River Red which is their Oktoberfest brew. Their other fall seasonal is the Cranberry Special Ale made with cranberries grown here in Wisconsin.



Something that the brewery introduced this summer was a hard lemonade. I have had it and I like it quite a bit, though it can get too sweet. I'll say more about it in a separate entry.

The MBR crew listed a number of Oktoberfest events at their "Oktoberfest" entry. I would add that the Essen Haus here in Madison will be having its festivities on the 29th of this month. Also on that day will be the 4th Annual Bay View Pub Crawl in Milwaukee.

The following weekend on 6 October will be Quivey's Grove's 14th Annual Beer Fest.

On 22 September in Mount Horeb will be The Thirsty Troll Brew Fest. Mt. Horeb is, of course, home to the Grumpy Troll Brew Pub.

More events around the state from Suds, Wine and Spirits:

September 7 – 9
29th Annual MainStrasse Village Oktoberfest
Old Heidelberg Park, Glendale, WI

September 7 - 9, 14 - 16 & 21 – 23
United German Societies Oktoberfest
The Bavarian Inn, 700 Lexington, Glendale, WI

September 8
Brown Ales & Merlot Wine Tasting - 1-6 PM – Free
Three Cellars, 6955 S. 27th St., Franklin, WI

September 8
Wisconsin Rapids Lions 5th Annual Fall Brew Review - 1-6 PM
Robinson Park, Wisconsin Rapids, WI
(715) 423-0669 - ottlarry17@yahoo.com

September 8
7th Annual Clearwater Beer Fest - $25 ($22.50 Advance)
Eau Claire County Expo Park, Eau Claire, WI

September 13
Delafield Brewhaus Oktoberfest - Keg Tapping @ 5 PM
Delafield Brewhaus, Delafield, WI

September 15
4th Annual Great Lakes Brewfest - 4-8 PM
Racine on the Lake Festival Park, 5 Fifth St., Racine, WI

September 22
5th Annual Big Lake Brew Fest
Wessman Arena, UW Superior, Big Lake, WI

September 28
12th Annual Septembeerfest - 8-11 PM - $30
Oak Creek Community Center, 8580 South Howell Ave., Oak Creek, WI - (414) 768-5840

September 28 – 29
Old World 3rd Street Oktoberfest
Milwaukee, WI

Raise One For the Beer Hunter



The Beer Hunter, Michael Jackson, died a little over a week ago. He was a consummate and tireless promoters of good beer through his writing and even a long out of print television show. His work helped transform our notions of beer as a strictly blue collar drink and elevated brew into an art, on par with fine wine. Jackson was instrumental in helping Belgian beers find a wide audience here in the States.

He was 65.

05 September, 2007

People Are the Main Spring

UW Philosophy professor Lester Hunt recently wrote a post at his blog called "Completely Rebuild New Orleans? Sorry No." in which he argues against restoring the city to its pre-Katrina state. The issue of how to rebuild New Orleans is certainly contentious and Prof. Hunt's general position is certainly not one that I, someone who is ambivalent on the matter, want to dismiss out of hand. But I am sorely disappointed, if not outright dismayed, at how he chose to write about his opinion on the matter.

He argues that we (i.e. – taxpayers) shouldn't have to foot the bill to rebuild New Orleans in its entirety: "…completely rebuilding New Orleans would mean some of us indulging our sentimental attachments and aesthetic tastes at other people's expense". His solution?

Let's rebuild the parts of the city that make it great -- Tulane and the French Quarter, among others -- and move on. On to Baton Rouge, on to Houston! Some of the parts of the city that are just a place to live should be allowed to go the way of the Stutz Bearcat, the brontosaurus, and the liberal Republican.

Prof. Hunt does a great job of avoiding mentioning that the areas he does not want to pay to rebuild were mostly populated by poor black people. Indeed, he doesn't mention them at all and thusly tries to avoid race and, I would imagine, charges of racism. He does this by first saying, "I am a long time-time admirer of New Orleans, and of Creole and Cajun cuisine and music", as if admiring a couple genres of music and a regional cuisine somehow banishes all prejudices and makes one completely impartial. Instead of recognizing that his plan would actually affect human beings who somehow don't fit into his vision of what New Orleans is, he transmogrifies them into tracts of land. "Places to live" is a euphemism for the homes and lives of the poor and black. Those communities didn't have the romantic attraction of Rue Bourbon for the white libertarian(my term) university professor so they have to be reduced to mere areas of utility which are devoid of culture and all the intangibles that human beings create around adn amongst themselves regardless of where they may be. A couple paragraphs down Prof. Hunt notes: "Further, as I understand it, the parts that are below sea-level tend to be the parts that were built after the formation of the modern welfare state." Clever! Again, that actual human beings called those "parts" home is never directly stated and by using "modern welfare state" he can acknowledge that people lived there without ever having to mention them. Plus he gets to be critical of the evil, wasteful government that he despises. Two birds with one stone.

His argument comes down to not wanting to force "the taxpayers to repair all the bad effects of this government-caused mistake." It's mostly, if not all, about money so there's little wonder that he would neglect to humanize the situation. If he did, it would probably veer perilously close to "I don't want to spend my money to rebuild the home and communities of poor black people" and we all know that would go over like a lead balloon.

When confronted with trying to apply his reasoning to San Francisco and its attendant earthquakes, Prof. Hunt replies:

San Francisco can probably survive on the resources of people who find it profitable or in some other way worthwhile to pay for it. In other words, protecting the whole thing is worth the cost.

So, it's fair for taxpayers to fund projects that earthquake proof SF as much as possible because SF has rich private benefactors. But, since New Orleans doesn't seem to have such private benefactors, there shouldn't be a public one. If rich people find San Francisco profitable and thusly have much to lose, then why should taxpayers subsidize their businesses? They should pay for it since they have more to lose. If SF doesn’t need to suckle at the public teat, then why is Prof. Hunt saying that it's fine for them to do so?

Now I’m confused. This should hardly be surprising since I am without a PhD. If Prof. Hunt or anyone else does not want to pay to rebuild New Orleans to its pre-flood state, fine. If Prof. Hunt or anyone else (especially up on this side of the Mason-Dixon Line) wants to coerce the cities Houston or Baton Rouge, well, I guess good arguments can be made. But, please, don't gloss over the thousands and thousands of people whose lives were ravaged by the flooding and are now going to be affected by these actions; don't refer to their homes and communities derogatorily as mere "places to live" or the results of the modern welfare state so you can score points with your libertarian friends. Stop hiding certain parts of the tragedy under rhetorical cover.

I'm not accusing Professor Hunt of racism and I understand that the almighty dollar is an essential part of the recovery process regardless of what gets rebuilt and what doesn't. What got in my craw was that Prof. Hunt came across as issuing commands ex cathedra - Houston shall do this, Baton Rouge shall do that, and you poor folks will go here or there - without even paying lip service to the people who are going to make up the diaspora. Democracy Now! broadcasted from New Orleans last week and the programs were filled with the voices of the people who inhabit Prof. Hunt's "places to live" and to find them excluded in his post or reduced to inanimate units for economists and theoreticians to calculate was most disappointing.

04 September, 2007

Scott Milfred Has Hopped the Trolley

When the Madison Common Council meets tonight, it'll be considering, among other items, a resolution calling for Congress to begin impeachment proceedings against Bush and Cheney. Scott Milfred of the Wisconsin State Journal came down against the resolution, labeled it a waste of time, and predictably laid all the blame at the doorstep of Progressive Dane. For its part, PD has pointed out the error of Mr. Milfred's assertion as has party co-chair Lukas Diaz at his blog. In light of this, the proprietor of Caffeinated Politics and Councilman Tim Gruber have publicly written in favor of the disputed resolution.

There certainly seems to be no love lost at all between Bush & Co. and the various Madison players mentioned above. Everyone seems to agree that Bush has, in the words of Benjamin Franklin, "rendered himself obnoxious", but nary a mention is made castigating Congress. The Founding Fathers knew very well that the Executive Branch would be subject to men who sought to consolidate power. As Edmund Randolph noted:

The Executive will have great opportunitys of abusing his power; particularly in time of war when the military force, and in some respects the public money will be in his hands. Should no regular punishment be provided it will be irregularly inflicted by tumults & insurrections.

The ability to impeach is in our Constitution precisely because of a long line of men of which Bush is only a recent incarnation. (Though most of them were worse than our current president.) Human history is beset by men grabbing power, claiming authority, or in other ways dictating policy that is unmediated. For better or for worse, we do things by committee in this country, not by Executive fiat. The second that the words "impeachment is off the table" fell from Nancy Pilosi's lips, she should have been charged with dereliction of duty and removed from office. Didn't she swear to uphold the Constitution and not the Democratic party line? Our own senator, Russ Feingold, thinks that Bush and Cheney "may well have committed impeachable offenses", but steadfastly refuses to champion impeachment because he feels the Congress is unable to multitask. The only palliative the Democrats can offer is "ride the storm out". Well, REO Speedwagon song titles just don't cut it.

The resolution before our Common Council is not so much an anti-Bush statement as much as an attempt to implore the House of Representatives to do its Constitutionally-mandated job and hold the Executive Branch accountable for its high crimes and misdemeanors. Bush and his toadies are certainly worthy of vitriol and the criticism of the above-cited bloggers, but I am disappointed that my fellow Madisonians did not direct some at Congress. Milfred wrote: "Remember that Bush is leaving office anyway in little more than a year. By the time he were impeached, he'd already be gone." How many more heinous precedents are you willing to let be established to be taken advantage of by a future John Yoo, Mr. Milfred? Sixteen months is long enough for Bush to inflict more damage. Even if Bush were to actually protect our Constitution starting today and for the rest of his presidency, the damage has been done and it is compounded by a Congress who refuses to even consider impeachment, thusly allowing the dangerous precedents to stand. Riding the storm out, Mr. Milfred, does absolutely nothing to send a message to future executives that power grabs are unacceptable and will not be tolerated here. What did Edmund Burke tells us happens when good men do nothing? It is you, not the lefty politicos you berate, who are in the make-believe club. You are the one who takes the trolley trip into some la-la land where, once Bush is gone, our government suddenly becomes inundated with good, honorable men and women and where vigilance is unnecessary.

I'm not a big fan of local governments making proclamations on national policy but the resolution to be considered is not a policy, per se. It is not about trying to get Congress to vote the Lefty way. It's about getting Congress to do something that transcends party lines and something we all can agree upon - its job. For this, our Common Council can take a wee bit more time tonight.

02 September, 2007

Pecks of Peppers and Preserves

The North Side Farmer's Market was doing good business this morning when The Dulcinea and I arrived. It was my first time there and I think her's as well.



While not anywhere near as large as the Dane County Farmer's Market, the north side version benefits from not having as many yuppies drawing wagons that are the equivalent of SUVs around at a snail's pace. It suffers from a smaller variety but there were plenty of vegetables to be had as well as preserves, meat, and even a stand offering chili.









I had some of those chilies in a batch of pico de gallo that my friend Dogger and I made a couple weeks ago and, lemme tell ya, they are potent! There was also a stand selling apples but, having bought a country ton yesterday, I couldn't bring myself to buy any. The Dulcinea, however, did get a Ginger Gold which was nice and yellow with a blush. Very tasty – sweet with a bit of zest to it.

I also got to meet and chat with Lee Davenport who is the proprietor of Pamplemousse Preserves. I dated a former roommate of Lee's several years ago and I hoped that my ex didn't fill her head with nasty tales of me. Stepping up to her stand, she looked at me and commented that I was familiar to her. After revealing my identity, she opened up and we made small talk. Briana must have gone easy on me.



I bought a small jar of her Apricot and Pinot Grigio Preserves. Haven't tried them yet. Yet. However, I did sample her Black & Blue as well as the Black Currant & Pinot Noir preserves and they were fantastic.

I sure have a lot of cooking and preserving to do.

Going Deep Dish

With all the food shopping we did yesterday, I decided to make dinner using apples. To that end, I whipped up Beef and Apple Deep Dish Pie. It's not tremendously difficult but it is very time consuming.

The idea is to put beef stew in a doughy home. You season flour with cinnamon, mace, ginger, and pepper and then roll your stew meat in it and brown. Then sauté some onion. I used a Spanish onion that we'd bought at the orchard. Eating a couple slices of it raw was a real treat. My tongue was bathed in their tremendous sweetness and they were very juicy as well. These were the watermelons of the onion family. I threw in some bell pepper because our garden gave us a bounty of them. Once they're about done, pitch in the rest of your seasoned flour and cook so you have a bit of roux. Next, throw in the meat, vegetables, and your liquid – beef stock and red wine.



You end up with a simple stew which goes in a pie crust. My pie crust making ability is for shite. I prefer using lard but opted for vegetable shortening this time 'round as per The Dulcinea's request. I cut the shortening in with two forks and added water just a wee bit at a time but I couldn't get a ball to form by stirring so I ended up using my hands. I don't know why the ability to make good pastry dough eludes me so.

Here's a diagram showing pastry doughs at the molecular level courtesy of Harold McGee:



The middle section was what I was going for – flakiness. The upper half shows fat surrounding flour in an uncooked state while the lower bit is after baking. Last night I had to add a little extra water to get it to form a ball and perhaps this was too much. Resting the dough in the refrigerator not only lets the fats solidify again but it also gives the water time to distribute itself in the dough. I guess I just added to much because my dough wasn't as flakey as it ought to have been. Excess water causes the dough bits to stick instead of separate giving a nice light flakiness.

My failings aside, the recipe calls for a two quart dish. I lined one with dough and put my stew inside.



Then top it off with apple slices.



Here is it with a steam hole ready to get thrown into the oven.



I completely for got to egg wash the top and did so in a hurry by simply opening the over door and pulling the rack out a bit.



Hence the blotchy browning above. So, how did it turn out?



Well, aside from my rib-sticking crust it turned out on the mediocre side. What looks essentially like a big mess tasted good. It's just that it never bloody thickened! And I must remember to put more salt in the stew next time. Plus more apples. I really fucked it up now that I think about it. I definitely want to try this again with some modifications or, rather, additions. This will make a hearty meal come winter.

Apples, Apples Everywhere

Yesterday provided lots of entertainment options. Many folks headed over to Taste of Madison while others to the Capital Brewery for Firefest and the inaugural tapping of the year's Autumnal Fire. Being on-call for work until tomorrow morning, I didn't want to be near any beer-soaked festival because my will is weak. Instead The Dulcinea and I headed nort for a return visit to Lapacek Orchard. Their newsletter said that the mysterious Wolf River apples were ready a bit early and I just had to see them for myself.



Pulling up, we found the driveway rather crowded with a few cars, most of which were SUVs from Illinois. Stepping out of the car, we were greeted by the hound! He's just so big and fury and cuddly.



We moseyed to the store and saw walls lined with gourds galore along with pumpkins, and watermelon.





There was also a mean-eyed putty tat hanging out in the lawn.



Inside Kim was minding the store and she remembered up from our last visit. With September upon us, apple season is in full bloom and they were offering some pre-hoolied apple mixes such as for apple spice bread and apple streusel muffins. Plus there were canned apples and make-your-own caramel apple kits. The words "hot pepper" attract me like a moth to the flame and so I just couldn't resist buying a jar of the hot pepper mustard which, Kim informed us, was made by her mother-in-law.



In addition to food, the Lapaceks also sell craft items such as quilts and jewelry that they make. The Dulcinea makes necklaces and bracelets so she and Kim hit it off really well and chatted for a bit. Kim divulged that she is a "retired" engineer. With a youthful face that places her in her late 20s, she must have left the lab or drawing board quite early in her career for a life on an orchard. Meanwhile I continued to wander around and leave a trail of drool wherever I did go. Those red onions stared at me long and hard as did some of the Spanish variety. So we got a bit of both. And red potatoes too! Actually, I'll bet that the first things I took off of a table or shelf and put near the register was a couple caramel apples. They are addictive.

Were the Wolf River apples in? You betcha! Just take a look at these babies: (The apples, that is.)



Now compare the Wolf River to a Gala:



They're not quite the one-to-a-pie size, but they're still enormous. Kim was kind enough to let us sample 2 or 3 apples and we ended up buying bags of Wolf Rivers, Galas, and Wealthies. She even asked about my medieval apple fritters. Kim is a total sweetheart. She apologized much too much for having to change her daughter's diapers. No biggie. We can keep ourselves busy ogling apples and contemplating how many onions to purchase.

I really enjoy heading out there. It's nice to be able to purchase food directly from the folks who grow/produce the stuff. Plus the farm is just a relaxing atmosphere when contrasted with a big sterile square box that is the grocery store. I used a couple apples yesterday for dinner and am planning on making applesauce and apple butter to can. We also bought a bunch of corn which is going to end up in our freezers for a taste of warmer times when the chill descends upon us. We will probably head back next weekend for more. Kim told us that they'll have the first cider of the year ready by then.



On the way back to Madison we stopped in at Schultz's Market in DeForest. We'd both made the mistake of not having eaten before heading to the orchard and by this time we were famished. The D bought some pistachio fluff and a couple hot sticks while I bought some Italian and Hungarian sausage links as well as some incredibly thick bacon. I fried up the bacon this morning to break our fasts along with some hot rice cereal. I ran out of maple syrup recently so we put barley malt on the cereal. It tastes just like wort smells and this explains why I love Grape Nuts. The bacon too was delicious. Each slice was a bit less than a quarter inch thick and very narrow. It was smoked to perfection and it again made me realize just how sick & twisted religious prohibitions on pork are. For someone to deprive themselves of the culinary equivalent of orgasm because of some lunatic in the desert thousands of years is truly ridiculous.

Once into town, we made a final stop at Alex Polish American Deli at its new location on E. Wash and Alex himself was behind the counter with his trademark Highland moustache. Their new digs are smaller than their old ones on Monroe Street and I think a shelf was missing from the equation. Still, the sweets are still there along with the stuff that appeals to me. They had a variety or two of kielbasa that I don't recall seeing at the old store. There were Parówki Wieprzowe or pork wieners and I believe Starowiejska. Still no Jałowcowa (juniper berry sausage) though. That garlic ham and peppered pork loin are going to end up on my sandwiches for lunch next week if I don't eat it all by tomorrow.

Bobby Bryan @ The Brink Lounge

Friday night saw local bluesman Bobby Bryan and the Original Downtown Players performing at The Brink Lounge. It was the first time that either The Dulcinea or myself had been there and we both found it to be a nice place. The couches looked comfortable and it was dimly lit giving a nice mellow atmosphere. However, the establishment was not meant for the likes of your humble narrator. An extensive wine list warranted its own menu while the more general drink list included abundant fine spirits including lengthy columns of scotch and tequila. The lounge was dead when we arrived and I was the only person donning a t-shirt. I was on-call for work and was, much to my chagrin, unable to drink and I the bartender was visibly unamused at my order of their finest 7-UP. Bryan could be heard tuning up in an adjacent room.

Shortly before the show was set to begin, a large group of middle-aged folks came down the stairs as I was heading up. My fears that the show would be severely under-attended were allayed. Indeed, the venue filled up shortly after the performance began. The room featured a goodly sized stage flanked by an ornate spiral staircase with a dance floor before it. The lights were down low, which I appreciated, but the joint was, in my opinion, just too fancy for a night of gritty music. There was just something wrong with the scene. The audience consisted mostly of graying folk with the majority of men still clad in their business casual uniforms accessorized by the obligatory cell phone holster. However, when Bryan got down to business, the odd juxtaposition of music born of the hard times of Delta life and a mostly white audience which bespoke of at least a modicum of affluence, dissipated.

The band was in fine form. Bryan his trademark funky shirt and vest and The Dulcinea opined that such a shirt in a color more suitable for my melanin-deprived skin would look good on me. Drummer Rick Flowers had a Gustav Klimt t-shirt on and he spent his time behind the kit with a big toothy grin plastered on his face as he always does. Bassist Lon Walker's lanky frame didn't move much but his fluid playing was solid. Steve Skaggs' was off at the side of the stage hidden by shadows like Robert Fripp. He may be the least appreciated member of the band but his organ work is more than that of a mere yeoman. His playing fills out band's sound perfectly and his solos are always great.

I don't recall the set but "Forty Days" and Jimmy Reed's "Baby What You Want Me To Do" were aired as were tunes by Robert Cray and Johnny Copeland. Listening to them, it was easy to understand why they won the Wisconsin Blues Challenge – they are tight. I don't have to tell you that Bryan has the chops but I will say that one of the great pleasures of the show was how seamlessly the guys were able to move from blues to funk. One second Bryan is hammering out some classic blues solo and then next thing you know his foot has gravitated towards a wah-wah pedal and the beat has subtlety changed for the funkier.

As with the band's performance at the Madison Blues picnic, the atmosphere on stage was light-hearted with between song banter and Flowers alternately being congratulated for recently lost his bachelorhood and being given grief. During a set break, I was outside having a smoke and was joined by a younger woman who was also enjoying the show. Flowers came out for a smoke himself and the woman commented on how much she loves his playing and watching him with that big grin he always seems to have. Clyde Stubblefield may get all the press, but Flowers is still brilliant.

The crowd enjoyed every minute. By the second set, folks began to migrate onto the dance floor. Some younger folks had wandered in and joined the older members of the crowd but the dance floor was all-ages.

Bryan's next appearance is on the 8th at The Harmony.

31 August, 2007

Keep Those Wraps

Alderwoman Brenda Konkel has a post called "Mixed Messages" at her blog today about the now infamous "beer bus", i.e. – a Metro bus with a full wrap add for Miller Genuine Draft. Ms. Konkel observed:

While the UW is so focused on the drinking habits of UW Students and how to change the culture of drinking on campus; the City is talking about limiting alcohol licenses downtown; the public and periphery alders are up in arms about the drag on police resources we have in the downtown area due to drinking on campus; and the police are warning students to be careful when drinking late night because Kelly Nolans[sic] killer is still on the lose[sic]; at the same time we have this "beer bus" circulating around downtown sending a much different message.

What message is the ad relaying? Obviously for Ms. Konkel, who was (gasp!) drinking beer at the time she made her observation, the ad means "go out and drink until you puke". If you follow the "beer bus" link above, you can read about Kevin Hinckley who apparently thinks public spaces should be sterilized for that perennial favorite of moral crusaders everywhere – to protect the children. In objecting to ads for De Jope Bingo Hall, Hinckley said, "We don't need 'a little bit of Vegas' in Madison. This is where we raise children, not a place where we gamble." I hate to break this to Mr. Hinckley but gambling and child raising are not mutually exclusive. He would apparently be surprised to find that there are, in fact, families in Las Vegas. The city has a population of nearly 500,000 men, women, and children who are parts of – you guessed it – families. Just ask Heather Skyler.

Ads for beer appear on billboards as well as on another vehicle called a beer truck. These trucks can be seen parked near taverns, restaurants, and other facilities that serve suds in full view of children! OH MY FUCK! We are truly a depraved society if we let these trucks with their caustic ads for beer on the outside idle on our city streets in plain view. I mean, how else would a youth get the idea that intoxicating beverages exist? What, do you think there's such a thing as peer pressure? The situation with the bus is a mere ad on the outside but, to make matters worse, with the trucks, children on the street might find themselves in close proximity to and see actual beer! Imagine the young mind of a child that sees a barrel being hauled across the sidewalk. It is truly ruined forever.

We now have a mini-temperance movement here in Madison which is being fed by the likes of Mr. Hinckley who apparently can't walk around in public without finding a million things that strike fear into him. One of Hinckley's co-whiners is Susan De Vos was quoted as saying, "If kids are seeing alcohol and gambling and whatever being advertized on busses, that's contrary to the idea that people have of what the community stands for." Well, speaking as a community member, I don't think our community stands for wiping out everything in public that would let kids on to the fact that the world really isn't like a Disney movie. It is not a mixed message to tell children that there are foods adults can consume and activities in which adults can engage that they cannot.

30 August, 2007

Kill da Wabbit!

I noted earlier this month that Marcus' Westgate Theatre showed Pirates of the Caribbean 3 with Spanish subtitles and Spider-Man 3 dubbed in Spanish and with English subtitles. Channel 3000 reports that the theatre chain "will begin showing movies in Spanish at theaters in southeastern Wisconsin, according to company officials." While I don't know for certain, I would imagine that this move was made, not only to appeal to the growing Latino population here in Madison, but also as a bit of counter-programming against Sundance 608. The shiny new art house not only gave Westgate competition for films, but it also moved in just down the road. Westgate must have felt pressure and seems to be adjusting.

Well, tomorrow they will delve into an area that Sundance has, so far, been unwilling to go – revivals. To that end, a Looney Toons Festival begins tomorrow. Quite frankly, it appeals to me more blatantly than anything that will be at Sundance next week. (Though I do want to catch No End in Sight and Gypsy Caravan looks to be interesting.) I suspect that seeing "What's Opera Doc?" on the big screen where it was meant to be seen would be a joy beyond words. Thankfully, Sicko will no longer be at Sundance but Waitress shall remain. Hasn't it been playing there since the theatre opened back in May?

Moving towards campus, the UW Cinematheque has announced its fall season. The legendary Japanese director Kenji Mizoguchi will be featured along with post-1968 films by Jean-Luc Godard. Hail Mary, a favorite of mine, will be among them. Also look for a 6-film jaunt through the history of Russian science fiction cinema.

Me and My Favorite DPs

I read this morning that Oliver Stone has has cast Bruce Willis for his next project, a film about the My Lai Massacre. I'm a fan of Oliver Stone though I must admit that his post-U-Turn films have left me a bit cold. Neither Any Given Sunday nor Alexander really grabbed me and I've not yet seen World Trade Center. Concomitant to my waning interest in Stone's films was the dissolution of his working relationship with his long-time cinematographer Bob Richardson.



Together they made some truly great cinema with engaging plots told with spectacular technical prowess. The cramped radio booth in Talk Radio was enlarged with a perpetually moving camera; harsh lighting, use of varying film stocks, and more camera movement (and editing too) helped make JFK, Natural Born Killers, and Nixon feasts for the eyes as well as heart and brain. I just got hooked on those stories and how the cinematography, editing, and sound all colluded to tell them. Just thinking of his work makes me want to dust off my Super8 cameras and start shooting.

So, what's Bob Richardson doing now?

I am just giddy to read that he has teamed up again with this country's greatest documentarian, Errol Morris, for S.O.P.: Standard Operating Procedure, an examination of the Abu Ghraib torture scandal. Previously they had done Fast, Cheap & Out of Control and the shots of the topiary gardener at work with the incredibly harsh backlighting are iconic Richardson to my mind.

Another one of my favorite cinematographers is Janusz Kaminski who is now Steven Spielberg's DP.



They first collaborated on Schindler's List and I count that along with Amistad, Saving Private Ryan, and Minority Report as among their best work. The use of color – mainly washing it out – and Kaminski's tinkering with shutters has created some of the most visceral storytelling ever, in my humble opinion. He is currently shooting the fourth Indian Jones film but recently returned to his native Poland to shoot and direct Hania. His directorial debut, Lost Souls, wasn't great but I am still looking forward to his second go at it.

Darius Khondji is also one of my favorite cinematographers. He shot Delicatessen and The City of Lost Children before making his American debut with Se7en. This was followed by gorgeous work in Stealing Beauty and Evita before he returned to his trademark browns and grays in Alien: Resurrection.



Later this year will see the release of Funny Games, a remake of a film of the same name which is being directed by Michael Haneke, who also helmed the 1997 original. (Haneke's last film was Caché.) It will be interesting to see Khondji's return to horror/thriller as well as how the same director will remake his own work for the Hollywood moneymen.

A new addition to my list of favorite DPs is Emmanuel Lubezki. He shot Tim Burton's Sleepy Hollow in the late 1990s and then had the amazing trifecta of Lemony Snicket's A Series of Unfortunate Events, The New World, and Children of Men in the middle of this decade. I need to start viewing his back catalog.



Currently he is doing the Coen Brothers' latest, Burn After Reading. But I still adore the work of Roger Deakins.

Lastly I want to make a nod to Joel Ransom. I saw his name pop up a week or two ago when I watched the first episode of ABC's Masters of Science Fiction. Ransom worked on The X-Files for a spell where he caught the attention of me and my film-geek friends. He stayed in television and went on to the Band of Brothers mini-series and the Battlestar Galactica TV movie for the Sci-Fi Channel. (Don't laugh – Vittorio Storaro shot their Dune mini-series.) Well, Ransom has finally made the move to the big screen with the fantasy epic The Dark is Rising.



Do you, dear reader, have favorite directors of photography?

29 August, 2007

A Wisconsin Story

We Cheeseheads love to flaunt our great natural expanses, our great beer, and, of course, our tasty cheeses. But tales of life here in the Dairyland go beyond Ole and Lena all the way to Harvey and Edwin:

Police stopped a truck in Abbotsford recently and found Harvey Miller, 43, was steering the truck. Miller has no legs.

Officers said that Edwin Marzinske, 55, was operating the gas pedals and brake.

The police report said Miller admitted he was too drunk to drive, but argued he wasn't actually operating the truck because he couldn't push the gas pedal.

28 August, 2007

Chicagoans Are Lucky to Have Us Cheeseheads

Beer drinkers down in Chitown now have a new brew - Half Acre Lager. It is the product of Half Acre Beer Company of Chicago and started shipping last week.



But as this article in the Chicago Reader points out, the beer is contract brewed by Sand Creek up in Black River Falls. First we gave them places to go and things to do during the summer and now we brew their beer. Cofounder Gabriel Magliaro notes that "opening a brewery in the city of Chicago is notoriously difficult and notoriously expensive". I suppose there are a lot of city officials to pay off. If you should find yourself in Bucktown or Wicker Park, stop in at the following locations to sample: Jerry’s, Pint, the Charleston, the Always Open convenience store at Milwaukee and Wabansia, and the 7-Eleven on Damen across from the park. If you're a Cheesehead visiting Chitown, it allows you to drink local and support a Wisconsin brewer all at the same time.

27 August, 2007

Review: Passion is a Fashion: The Real Story of The Clash by Pat Gilbert


Rock bios are a hit or miss affair. Sometimes they're hastily published to capitalize on the new-found success of a band or musician and contain little substance. However, books about established artists can be equally as worthless. All too often such texts are strict chronological records which never try to justify their existence by telling the reader why the artist being profiled is important. I've long admired Dave Marsh's account of The Who in his Before I Get Old. He imposed a narrative on the events he chronicled and cast Pete Townshend as the hero with Keith Moon as his foil. Whatever you may think of Marsh's tale, he constructed a nimble tale which was also an argument for the importance of The Who and their legacy which makes for much more interesting reading than "first this happened and then that and then something else".

As a former editor at the English music magazine, MOJO, Pat Gilbert has the credentials to write a rock bio. This, combined with his unabashed love of The Clash, gives the reader every expectation that Passion is a Fashion will be a great read and Gilbert delivers. He makes a critical and nuanced case for The Clash as a very important band in the rock pantheon. In addition, Gilbert uses his story to examine rock music as populist art and art as commerce.

The late Joe Strummer is clearly the hero here as his background is the subject of the book's first chapter, though those of Mick Jones and Paul Simonon subsequently follow. Strummer is portrayed as a troubled genius who, through fits and starts, finally finds his identity and voice in The Clash. In fact, the book links the formative years of all the band's members to their days as rock stars. Being an American, some of Gilbert's slang and English cultural and place references went over my head, but he did a good job of explaining the malaise of mid-1970s England which gave birth to the punk movement. With a mission statement of "We're anti-Fascist, anti-violence, we're anti-racist, and we're pro-creative", the band's eponymous debut arrived in the spring of 1977. Besides being a seminal punk album, it also contained the seed of what would give The Clash their legacy and make them important: a cover of the reggae song "Police and Thieves" which was an international hit in 1976 for Junior Murvin.

The book patiently shows how this first murmur of combining rock with reggae led to further cross-breeding with dub and eventually saw the band perform and record with Jamaican reggae/dub artist Mikey Dread. When The Clash went to New York City, they picked up on rap and incorporated it into their sound. Gilbert points out that this ability to infuse the music of disaffected minorities, of the street, with rock'n'roll was their greatest asset. It may have led them away from punk, but it also allowed them to transcend it as well and become something other than a short-lived burst of anger and nihilism like their contemporaries, the Sex Pistols. And it is this legacy, as Gilbert asserts, which countless musicians have picked up on over the years.

While the author is clearly enamored of his subject, he gives criticism when it's due. For instance, he exposes the hypocrisy of the band and their anti-violence stance by recounting several instances of band members getting into brawls both onstage and off. And Gilbert's case for The Clash as musical innovators isn't damped by his acknowledgment that they recorded some real duds in their time. Plus he notes how the callousness of the band as they publicly denounced members of its entourage who were expelled.

Just as with The Who in Before I Get Old, the idealism of The Clash runs headlong into commercialism and the Big Bad Record Company. While it's not fair to place all the blame at the doorstep of CBS Records, the absolutely ridiculous contract they had with the band created lots of friction. Living up to all of one's ideals is difficult with a record company on your back demanding product and bills to be paid. But unlike his fellow writer, Gilbert sees the story of The Clash through to the bitter end. Marsh declared The Who dead in 1978 when Keith Moon died and paid only lip service to the following four years. Gilbert, on the other hand, retains his level of analysis in detailing the last couple years of The Clash's existence after Mick Jones and Topper Headon were gone. Those days were not pretty but they're part of the story.

That fans of The Clash will enjoy Passion is a Fashion is a no-brainer. But even I as a less than die-hard enthusiast of the band found it to be a great read and so will anyone who is passionate about rock music. This is because the book is about more than chronicling the nine or so years of The Clash's existence. It's a great tribute to the malleability of rock music which makes it so powerful to musicians and fans alike. In its page is also a look at the intersection of art and commerce as well as a more personal tale about imperfect people who were never quite able to live up to their ideals.

Review: The Treats - Reservoir Tales


The Treats are a power trio hailing from right here in Madison. Reservoir Tales is the band's sophomore effort and it mysteriously appeared in my mailbox over the weekend. Unsolicited but quite welcome.

Formed at the tail end of the last millennium, the group features brothers Andrew and Don Isham on guitar and percussion, respectively, with Tim Payne on bass. Andrew provides lead vocals but everyone contributes their voices. The term "power trio" conjures up Cream to my mind and they're not a wholly bad starting point because Reservoir Tales has plenty of bluesy riffing and the occasional nod to psychedelia. And the sonic improvement here over their debut album, Paint Your Blood (2004) means that Don's drums don't sound like Ginger Baker's as they did on that album, i.e. – recorded in a cardboard box. The sound here is expansive with each member given plenty of breathing room yet it can't be accused of being overly-polished. Lo-fi garage rock aesthetics have perhaps been transmogrified into medium-fi but the rawness and immediacy remain.

The chunky riffing on songs like the opener, "Second Hand Reserve", may bring The White Stripes to mind but, when "Cuchillo" starts south of the border only to speed north and come crashing into a finale of Blue Cheer pandemonium, it beggars comparison. "Ever Been Down" is perhaps as close to the blues as a group of engineering majors can get with its neo-boogie that gives the North Mississippi All-Stars a run for their money.

Reservoir Tales, like its predecessor, is committed to dynamics. Just as with Jethro Tull's Aqualung, in between the riff-laden heavier tunes are mostly acoustic ditties. "Blind and Undying" is a comforting bit of ragged acoustic pop that is colored with sitar. Andrew Isham won't go down as the heir to Ravi Shankar's legacy but it's effective and the short raga jam which closes the song pays nice tribute to late 1960s psychedelia. If lullabies could have lines like "You'll do what it is that killed you", then I suppose "Without a Word" would indeed be one. Instead the gently plucked acoustic evokes Genesis from their brief pastoral period with such pieces as "Dusk".

While it's easy to spot a nod here and a stolen riff there, Reservoir Tales comes off, not as derivative, but as a billet-doux to great rock music through the ages. The brothers Isham and Mr. Payne are solid players. And from the short, incisive phrases on "Cuchillo" to the manic screaming on "Like an Animal", Andrew has a great rock voice. My favorite song at the moment is "Eve's Playground" which has a surf rock beat underneath but is all Link Wray on top. Even the vocals aren't that far removed from what Wray did on songs like his cover of "Ain't That Lovin' You Baby". When Andrew sings "You never lick my wounds when I've been cut", you know he means it. I'm not sure what that means, but I believe him just the same. It is probably the catchiest rock song anyone in Madison has recorded since Mad Trucker Gone Mad committed "Cows in the Pasture" to CD.

Reservoir Tales will be released on 7 September with a CD release show to follow that evening at the King Club. Joining them will be two other great local bands - Cash Box Kings and The Selfish Gene.

She Should Work for the Bush Administration

Her ability to give a complete non sequitur as as answer should assure her of a place in government.


Brilliant Answer From Ms South Carolina - Watch more free videos

Gonzales Takes Off, Eh

Attorney General Alberto Gonzales has resigned. Now, does anyone really think the Dems will actually try to get someone in their who is concerned more with applying the laws of our land than towing party lines? Personally I think we're gonna get stuck with more of the same.

24 August, 2007

The Winner Is...Dane101!

Congratulations to Dane101 for having been voted Best Local-Content Blog in this year's Isthmus poll. I'll submit a memo to the beer desk anon. Now if the Breakfast Links could stop adhering to the "if it bleeds, it leads" thing. The section is turning into the front page of the WSJ/TCT.

23 August, 2007

Fretoure of Fayre Applys

Upon getting home from work this evening, I immediately began cooking. It was time to do something with some of the goodies from the garden. One obvious tasty treat to make would be pico de gallo.

Tomatoes. We've got tomatoes. My pico ended up with the trifecta of cherry, Roma, and beefsteak toms. On the pepper side I had picked green Bells and Hungarian wax(?) and several ended up on the chopping block. Lastly there was that red onion which I had bought at Lapacek's Orchard. To finish it off, I put in lots of garlic, lime juice, and no cilantro because I didn't have any despite thinking that I did. It turned out rather colorfully and it sits in the refrigerator as the marriage of the flavors is consummated.



With that being done, I set out to recreate yet another medieval recipe – Apply Fretoure. Here is the original:

Take whete floure, Ale 3est, Safroun, & Salt, & bete alle to-gederys as þikke as þou schuldyst make oþer bature in fleyssche tyme; & þan take fayre Applys, & kut hem in maner of Fretourys, & wete hem in þe bature vp on downne, & frye hem in fayre Oyle, & caste hem in a dyssche; & caste Sugre þer-on, & serue forth.

I'm not sure of the date but hails from sometime in the first half of the 15th century and is, as you can see, an English recipe.

To start, heat a bit of beer (Viking Weathertop Wheat, in this case) so it's just warm and add your yeast. Just look at the wee yeasties in their bath!



Here's the beer and saffron. Bruise the saffron in a small amount of hot beer.



Throw all your beer in a bowl along with flour, salt, and sugar. Mix it up and you've have a smooth, wonderfully aromatic batter. Let it rise for a spell.



With the batter doing its thing, I reached into our magic pantry and grabbed the first bag of apples I saw – Zestars. Dip your apple bits in it, and fry. I cut my fruit into bite-size chunks – finger food.



I topped them off with powdered sugar & cinnamon.



They were really tasty! I called The Dulcinea, who was out with a friend, to tell her just how good they were. The batter fried up nice'n'crispy yet fluffy and the flavors of the apples melded incredibly well with the saffron.

The recipe was certainly not 100% authentic. Fried in vegetable oil? Perhaps next time I'll use a mixture of oil and lard. The Zestars are a very new variety of apple as they were developed, methinks, in the early 1990s. Lastly, a wheat beer most certainly wouldn't have been used. Hops was introduced to England around the same time this recipe was transcribed so it's likely that an ale flavored with herbs was used. As Wikipedia notes:

In the past, other plants have been used for similar purposes; for instance, Glechoma hederacea. Combinations of various aromatic herbs, berries, and even ingredients like wormwood would be combined into a mixture known as gruit and used as hops are now used.

The recipe notes that the batter is the same as that made on meat days ("in fleyssche tyme") so these fritters were likely meant to be eaten during Lent or, at least, on Fridays. Being a godless heathen, I say they're good anytime.

Do The Jerk

Earlier this week I spent some time out in the garden getting eaten alive by mosquitoes and picking vegetables. Peppers are not something that we're short on.



Somehow we (i.e. - Stevie) neglected to plant any jalapenos or cayennes ergo any plans for making jelly or hot sauce from the fruits of the garden are lost. However, we do have a couple habenera plants and, despite the fact that they're drowning now, they did enjoy the hot temperatures earlier this month.



So what does one do with lots of habeneras? Make jerk paste, of course!



I cried and sniffled the whole way through. Chopping the onion with my shiny, new, and highly sharp knife got the waterworks going first. (And I managed to cut myself too!) Then I cleaned the chilies. With a lack of latex gloves and against my better judgment, I did so with bare hands. Even though the process took place under a stream of cold water, the toxic capsaicin vapors still penetrated my nasal cavity. Uff da! My hands burned well into the next day forcing me to use tissue paper for handling my tender parts when using the commode. I crushed the allspice berries with my mortar & pestle (thanks, grandma!) and added the result along with goodly doses of thyme, molasses, salt, freshly ground black pepper, etc. The result?



Some got thrown in the freezer while the jar is in the frig. I suspect this stuff can adequately substitute for paint stripper and, if Rachel Carson were still around, she'd no doubt inveigh against it. So it should be tasty.

I think tonight I'll plunder the garden a bit more, if I don't drown. We've got 80 tons of cherry tomatoes so they're not going to get canned. Perhaps I'll whip up a batch of pico de gallo of the gods. I am also keen on making some medieval apple fritters. The recipe isn't overly specific and calls for a batter just like any one would make "in fleyssche tyme", i.e. - on days when folks we're allowed to eat meat. I found some unpasteurized beer in the form of Viking's Weathertop Wheat which I think will do the trick. If my plan goes according to plan, I'll be changing employers soon and will attempt to use up my vacation time before I bail. I'd like to drag The Dulcinea up nort and visit the brewery, amongst other pleasures.

Buy My Rug!

People who know me know that I prefer carpeting to tile but this rug has got to go.



It's 7.5'x9.5' and made of 100% wool. Bought in 1985. Needs a cleaning but otherwise in good condition. It's nice and soft and warm and in a style which has no appeal to me. Any locals looking to accent their Midwestern home in a Southwestern style?

22 August, 2007

"Drunk Astronauts" Story is Bullshit

You may remember the story about drunken astronauts that appeared in the news last month which brought up mental images of the space shuttle being manned by a bunch of lushes who were all tanked up. Well, James Oberg has a few things to say about this.

Crime Scene Investigator Busted


Crime Scene Investigator Busted - Watch more free videos

It's Happiness Returns to Madison



The polka documentary It's Happiness, which screened earlier this year at the Wisconsin Film Festival, will be returning to Madison next month. (My review of the film is here.) Details of the return:

Orpheum Theatre
Wednesday, September 26th at 7pm and 9:30pm

Expect some live polka before the screenings and an after party at The Essen Haus.

Nemesis



My drives to and from work have had a shadow fall over them recently. It started when I began listening to the audiobook of Chalmers Johnson's Nemesis in my car. On one hand, it's an utterly fascinating look at our government and various elements of our foreign policy since the end of World War II. On the other, it is a chronicle of horror with, among other things, the CIA acting as a tentacle of the Executive Branch with a secret budget and no oversight. I am currently in media res of the sorry story of how two Marines and a sailor abducted, beat and raped a twelve-year-old girl on the island of Okinawa where we have no less than 37 military bases. Prior to this, Johnson gave overviews of the Roman and British empires, a look at the CIA including an in-depth explanation of my country's role in the overthrow of Chilean president Salvador Allende in 1973, and lots of discussion about the concentration of executive power & the military-industrial complex. Every morning and afternoon I feel like Kevin Kostner's Jim Garrison being lectured to by Mr. X.



It's not that Johnson is L. Fletcher Prouty but the reader has my rapt attention as I listen and I find the words enlightening, if sad and angering as well. There is a lot of history and arguments in Nemesis to which I cannot do justice and, besides, I'm not even three quarters of the way through it. The broadest lesson is that America is an empire. Different from those of Rome and Britain, but an empire nonetheless. Johnson sites the Pentagon's Base Structure Report which lists 737 military bases scattered across every continent on the globe in some 130 countries. He cites this and continues to note what's missing from the report before giving his own tally of 1000+ bases. Our military budget is similarly scrutinized and assigned a total of somewhere around $750,000,000,000. That's a lot of zeroes. With 1000+ bases as part of a total military budget of three quarters of a trillion dollars, the suitability of the word "empire" can be in little doubt.

It was bad enough to listen to accounts of the CIA as a rogue arm of the presidency and a description of the military-industrial complex, but perhaps the worst blow came as I heard about the military bases that are currently in and the ones we're building in Iraq. By "we" I mean American taxpayers essentially giving corporate welfare to one subsidiary of Haliburton or another. And then there's the Orwellian misuse of language when the military refers to these outposts as "enduring" instead of "permanent". It made me realize that the question "When are we going to get out of Iraq?" is fraught with ambiguities despite it being rather straightforward on it face. To the average American citizen, the question no doubt conjures up images of our fighting men & women and all of their equipment being loaded onto C-130s and transport ships which take off or leave port. On the other hand, I highly suspect that the question to our politicos and captains of industry means something a bit different. I think that, to these people, "getting out of Iraq" means handing over the routine duties of law enforcement over to the Iraqis and sending the majority of our troops home while the 3 or 4 bases that the Pentagon wants to keep come hell or high water are populated by the remaining troops. In the political sense, getting out of Iraq means retreating to our multi-billion dollar bases, not actually leaving the borders of the country. Our embassy there is to be the biggest one in the world and we're spending billions of dollars to build military bases there that are to endure. Strictly speaking, we're not going to leave Iraq. Even if the Iraqis stood up tomorrow and took over all policing duties and assembled as army for national defense and drove out all the terrorists – we'd still have a presence there. Even if the Kurds and the Sunnis and the Shiites miraculously all found a way to live in harmony, we'd still have our military bases there. To average Joes and Janes, getting out of Iraq is about leaving. By contrast, to those in power, it is about what we leave behind.

There is an ongoing intra-lefty debate about the lesser of two evils. Just mention the name of Ralph Nader when you're in a room of lefties and you'll see what I mean. Nader asserts that there's no real differences between the two major parties in this country. While progressives might agree, your more garden variety liberal is likely to take issue with this. A common retort is to point out abortion. Dems are generally pro-choice while Republicans are generally in favor of having Roe v Wade overturned. The point is taken but I would note that most liberals who refute Nader's statement look to domestic policies when arguing in opposition. Listening to Nemesis and attempting to take a broader view which is inclusive of our foreign policy, I think that Nader is, at least partially, redeemed. Presidents of both parties have eagerly used the power of the CIA for decidedly undemocratic purposes; and no President nor seemingly any Congressperson of either party has ever tried to restrain our country's militarism or the military industrial complex of the past 60 years. Eisenhower's warning has gone unheeded.



I'm not advocating that those on the left side of the political spectrum ought to stop voting for Democrats. But I do think we should consider Johnson's warnings and what one can draw from them: merely putting a Dem in the White House in 2008 doesn't mean that all American troops will be brought home or that America will cede its authority on the world stage. Even anti-war Congresspeople fight tooth and nail to keep the military bases in their districts from closing. My roommate Stevie blames Nader and advocates for progressive candidates on the local level. While having them serve on our school boards, in our state legislatures, etc. is certainly a good thing, conceding to the lesser of two evils in national offices is to concede to militarism, which is, according to Johnson, why the terrorists hate us.

EDIT: You can watch a recent interview with Chalmers Johnson at the Conversations With History site at the UC Berkeley.

Lingerie and Pajama Party

20 August, 2007

Martin E. Marty: Lazy or Liar?

Bill Moyers hosted a conversation last week with Martin E. Marty, a historian and the Fairfax M. Cone Distinguished Service Professor Emeritus at the University of Chicago. I found him to be quite interesting and also quite infuriating. I took great exception to the following comments:

I've been invited several times to debate one of the new school of atheists…And as you and every listener has to know that these four or five all say that if you just get rid of all religion the world would be benign and peaceful.

Well-- my question is how do you explain Mao and Stalin and Lennon and all of the great totalitarians, all of whom set out to get rid of God and religion and killed several hundred million people. I'm not defending the religious record. There's horrible stuff out there.

And I make a lot of my living in my noisy books about describing that. But you're not going to get rid of religion. You can't suppress this impulse.


I have a lot of issues with these remarks. Firstly is the bit about the new school of atheists. People like Sam Harris, Richard Dawkins, Christopher Hitchens, and Daniel Dennett are, I would argue, very old school atheists. As Preston Jones has noted, Hitchens (and this applies more or less to all these guys) didn't come up with anything new in his jeremiad. True but irrelevant. Nearly 2,300 years ago Epicurus wrote:

Is God willing to prevent evil, but not able? Then he is not omnipotent.
Is he able, but not willing? Then he is malevolent.
Is he both able and willing? Then whence cometh evil?
Is he neither able nor willing? Then why call him God?

Over two millennia later, Bertrand Russell published his classic Why I Am Not a Christian. There is no new school for atheists because they reiterate arguments that adherents of religion are unable to counter. If there is anything new to be had, it's an attitude that they're not going to be relegated to being a tolerated minority by the religious majority. These men stand on the shoulders of giants, as it were, and to casually dismiss them is to dismiss centuries of criticisms and arguments.

The second bit with which I take issue is the notion that Messrs. Dawkins, Harris, Hitchens, and Dennett promote the notion that, if religion were to disappear, we'd suddenly find ourselves in some prelapsarian paradise. This is complete and utter bullshit. Either Marty hasn't bothered to listen to the Four Musketeers or he told on a bold-faced lie. He is either intellectually lazy or just a liar. Dawkins' essay "Time to Stand Up" refutes Marty's ludicrous and quite plainly stupid assertion/lie. Here are some excerpts:

How can I say that religion is to blame? Do I really imagine that, when a terrorist kills, he is motivated by a theological disagreement with his victim? Do I really think the Northern Ireland pub bomber says to himself "Take that, Tridentine Transubstantiationist bastards!" Of course I don't think anything of the kind. Theology is the last thing on the minds of such people. They are not killing because of religion itself, but because of political grievances, often justified.

My point is not that religion itself is the motivation for wars, murders and terrorist attacks, but that religion is the principal label, and the most dangerous one, by which a "they" as opposed to a "we" can be identified at all. I am not even claiming that religion is the only label by which we identify the victims of our prejudice. There's also skin color, language, and social class.

The human psyche has two great sicknesses: the urge to carry vendetta across generations, and the tendency to fasten group labels on people rather than see them as individuals. Abrahamic religion gives strong sanction to both--and mixes explosively with both.


Religion has a most potent ability to exacerbate problems and to give focus to our darker sides. Of course the dissipation of religion won't make everything OK but the removal of religion is like the removal of a tank of gasoline being poured on a fire.

What about those godless cretins like Stalin? As Dawkins has said on many occasions, it was not his atheism which was the cause of his evil. No one is claiming that to be godless automatically makes one morally perfect. And even Marty admits that religion doesn't exactly have the best track record. Here's Hitchens' take:

Hitler never abandoned Christianity and recommends Catholicism quite highly in “Mein Kampf.” Fascism, as distinct from National Socialism, was in effect a Catholic movement.

For hundreds of years, millions of Russians had been told the head of state should be a man close to God, the czar, who was head of the Russian Orthodox Church as well as absolute despot. If you’re Stalin, you shouldn’t be in the dictatorship business if you can’t exploit the pool of servility and docility that’s ready-made for you. The task of atheists is to raise people above that level of servility and credulity. No society has gone the way of gulags or concentration camps by following the path of Spinoza and Einstein and Jefferson and Thomas Paine.


Harris:

People of faith regularly claim that atheism is responsible for some of the most appalling crimes of the 20th century. Although it is true that the regimes of Hitler, Stalin, Mao and Pol Pot were irreligious to varying degrees, they were not especially rational. In fact, their public pronouncements were little more than litanies of delusion--delusions about race, economics, national identity, the march of history or the moral dangers of intellectualism. In many respects, religion was directly culpable even here. Consider the Holocaust: The anti-Semitism that built the Nazi crematoria brick by brick was a direct inheritance from medieval Christianity. For centuries, religious Germans had viewed the Jews as the worst species of heretics and attributed every societal ill to their continued presence among the faithful. While the hatred of Jews in Germany expressed itself in a predominately secular way, the religious demonization of the Jews of Europe continued. (The Vatican itself perpetuated the blood libel in its newspapers as late as 1914.)

Auschwitz, the gulag and the killing fields are not examples of what happens when people become too critical of unjustified beliefs; to the contrary, these horrors testify to the dangers of not thinking critically enough about specific secular ideologies. Needless to say, a rational argument against religious faith is not an argument for the blind embrace of atheism as a dogma. The problem that the atheist exposes is none other than the problem of dogma itself--of which every religion has more than its fair share. There is no society in recorded history that ever suffered because its people became too reasonable.


Marty also says that the religious impulse cannot be suppressed. Well, certain European countries are doing a pretty good job - Sweden, Denmark, France, and Holland, for example. And, when he talks about all the thousands of folks in Africa and Latin America becoming Christians everyday, one must ask – why is it that people of wealthier/more educated nations seem to be able suppress the religious impulse in such numbers while people in poorer nations seemingly cannot? I don't think any of the Four Musketeers believe that religion is going to be eradicated; certainly not anytime soon. Hitchens remarks as much often. He accepts that there will always be religious adherents but he wants them to support secular society by leaving their beliefs at home and to stop imposing them onto him. Sam Harris has said numerous times that his goal is to open a dialogue and to remove the stigma on criticism of religion. He wants to pull it down from its privileged perch so it can be discussed openly instead of the religious always being given the benefit of the doubt and undue deference. Similarly, Dennett wants religion to be thought of as something within the purview of science, not some enigma in a society which would castigate those who sought to scrutinize it. And Dawkins is keen on spreading science & reason and to get people to dispel myths about evolution such as the canard that humans evolved from apes.

The last thing I want to say about Marty's comments pertains to his refusal to debate any of these folks. I think he mistaken implies that any such debate would be about the existence of Yahweh. Debates with any of the FM generally aren't about dissecting the Ontological Argument for the Existence of God, they are about the pervasiveness of religion and the effects of it. They argue about practical matters and for a secular state knowing full well that religion will be, if I may say, an albatross around the neck of humanity for some time to come.

I don't know if Marty is just lazy or whether he intentionally lied. Either way it's a disgrace and a shame.

Punching Out Death Cab for Cuties in the Factory


A blogger named Bridget recently wrote a ham-fisted post entitled "The biggest little thing you've never heard (of)". Unfortunately it probably should have been titled "The Madison Music Scene Sucks Because There Aren't Enough Indie Rock Bands I Like". Don't people like Bridget ever get tired of whining about how their tastes in music aren't represented on every fucking street corner in Madison? You'd think that the Sword of Damocles was hanging over their heads so that, if they should dare to listen to non-indie rock, their lives would end in a skull-splitting crescendo. That there is not an industry catering to your every indie rock need doesn't mean that "there's really nothing super exciting going on in Madison music". What it means is you need to expand your tastes in music. And I just love her standards of quality. If Madison doesn't produce a Death Cab for Cutie, Ani DiFranco, Atmosphere or a Girl Talk, then the "scene" here must be as limp as a pre-Viagra pecker. That our fair city is unable to produce enough Death Cab for Cuties is surely a sign of its failure and some future Stu Levitan will point to this in a multi-volume set about the fall and decline of Madison. What is it about these bands/musicians that just screams artistic quality and should be the gold standard by which a "scene" is judged? Do folks in other cities castigate their hometowns because they too cannot produce the nearest generic equivalent of Death Cab for Cutie?

Townies can't create any Bridget-approved music because "they're too caught up in their drama filled worlds in between shifts at Whole Foods and Captel to make anything of real artistic value." Yeah, unless you dedicate yourself to your music and ditch that job, there's no way to fulfill Bridget's definition of artistic value. If only Muddy waters had quit his day job as a sharecropper – maybe then he'd have made some music that was really artistic and of lasting value. Wait, he did. Mr. Morganfield quit being a sharecropper and then got a job in a factory. If only he'd dedicated himself to his art in a manner consistent with Bridget's strict guidelines. Is that all creativity is these days? Whether or not you work a day job? That one is not starving does not render one incapable of relaying emotion and angst in music. The overly romantic notion that great music is only produced by suffering musicians who'd rather wallow in abject poverty than be forced to work should, by now, be known to be a fraud. I implore you, please stop perpetuating the starving artist myth.

If you ask the question as to why Madison is not constantly producing bands like Death Cab for Cutie, I can honestly say I don't know. Personally, I think it's a good thing. That Madison is not an assembly line for musical groups consisting of mostly white, mostly male hipsters that go on to some national recognition is not a bad thing. Just because Bob Boilen doesn't rhapsodize about any Madison bands on his radio show, doesn't mean that we're bereft of talent. While musicians leave town for larger cities like Chicago and New York, we as a city also underutilize some great folks. Jan Wheaton should have a reputation here like Koko Taylor does in Chicago. The city of Munich, Germany commissions Roscoe Mitchell to write music while most Madisonians have no idea who he is and probably couldn't care either. Hence he performs here – what? – once a year at the Isthmus Jazz Festival?

If you think Madison's indie rock scene blows, fine. Say so, if you will. But don't drag the whole scene down with it. We've got a kick-ass symphony orchestra and, against all known laws of art, this town of a mere 225,000 sports an opera company; I can bang my head to The Ottoman Empire on a Friday and spend the next evening down at Madison Center for Creative & Cultural Arts with Hanah Jon Taylor and others improvising jazz; against all odds we've got the Balkan lounge funk of the Reptile Palace Orchestra and the klezmer of Yid Vicious, the math rock of Arp of the Covenant and the Creole sounds of the Cajun Strangers, and the Latin jazz of the Tony Castañeda Latin Jazz Sextet is often heard coming from the Cardinal while Bruce Bolerud's polka strains are to be found down the street at the Essen Haus. How dare you say there's nothing super exciting happening musically here in Madison! How dare you insult all of these people and countless musos in this town who bust their humps playing for folks only to encounter the whining of indie rock fans who just can't make big enough gluttons of themselves at the Pitchfork-approved trough.

I will shout this from rooftops until my voice leaves me:

THE MADISON MUSIC SCENE IS NOT THE SOLE PROVINCE OF WHITE INDIE ROCKERS!