(Thanks to Ed Brayton for drawing this to my attention.)
Democracy certainly has its drawbacks. Ergo we have a republic with ruling power divided amongst three branches of government including a bicameral legislature. But this isn't enough for someone named Philip Atkinson who advocated dictatorship. His piece was posted last week at the website of Family Security Matters but has since been taken down. Indeed, just about every mention of him has been wiped. Fortunately, there is the Google cache so you can still read Atkinson's advocacy for making George Bush into Caesar. Here are some choice excerpts:
The wisest course would have been for President Bush to use his nuclear weapons to slaughter Iraqis until they complied with his demands, or until they were all dead. Then there would be little risk or expense and no American army would be left exposed. But if he did this, his cowardly electorate would have instantly ended his term of office, if not his freedom or his life.
If President Bush copied Julius Caesar by ordering his army to empty Iraq of Arabs and repopulate the country with Americans, he would achieve immediate results: popularity with his military; enrichment of America by converting an Arabian Iraq into an American Iraq (therefore turning it from a liability to an asset); and boost American prestiege while terrifying American enemies.
He could then follow Caesar's example and use his newfound popularity with the military to wield military power to become the first permanent president of America, and end the civil chaos caused by the continually squabbling Congress and the out-of-control Supreme Court.
That some crackpot with a developing martyr complex would write such trash is understandable. But that it was printed somewhere other than his own website flummoxes. Brayton points to this (rather sketchy) site which claims the following about Family Security Matters:
Well, it turns out that "Family Security Matters (FSM) is a front group for the Center for Security Policy (CSP), a conservative Washington think tank "committed to the time-tested philosophy of promoting international peace through American strength." (The phone number listed on the FSM website is answered by the CSP.)
http://www.sourcewatch.org/index.php?title=Family_Security_Matters
So now we are led to the Center for Security Policy, and who's connected to that group?
Dick Cheney, Vice President of the U.S. under George W. Bush, was an early member of Center's Board of Advisors (which is now called the National Security Advisory Council).
Twenty-two CSP advisers -- including additional Reagan-era remnants like Elliott Abrams, Ken deGraffenreid, Paula Dobriansky, Sven Kraemer, Robert Joseph, Robert Andrews and J.D. Crouch -- have reoccupied key positions in the national security establishment, as have other true believers of more recent vintage."
And don't forget Douglas Feith, Richard Perle, and Frank Gaffney.
I sincerely hope it was all a joke. But considering that Atkinson had several pieces up at the webpage, I am not so sure. I may blather on about my severe dislike of the Bush administration, but at least I don't call for ridding our country of democracy.
Getting rid of democracy was also on the mind of Dubya's grandpappy, Prescott. The BBC broadcasted a documentary about an attempted coup in 1933.
Document uncovers details of a planned coup in the USA in 1933 by right-wing American businessmen.
The coup was aimed at toppling President Franklin D Roosevelt with the help of half-a-million war veterans. The plotters, who were alleged to involve some of the most famous families in America, (owners of Heinz, Birds Eye, Goodtea, Maxwell Hse & George Bush’s Grandfather, Prescott) believed that their country should adopt the policies of Hitler and Mussolini to beat the great depression.
The Smirking Chimp provides a summary:
Some of the wealthiest men in America approached Marine Corps Major General Smedley Butler, beloved of many World War I veterans, many of them embittered by the government's treatment of them. Prescott Bush's group asked Butler to lead 500,000 veterans in a take-over of Washington and the White House. Butler refused and recounted the affair to the congressional committee. His account was corroborated in part by a number of witnesses, and the committee concluded that the plot was real. But the names of wealthy backers of the plot were blacked out in the committee's records, and nobody was prosecuted. According to the BBC, President Roosevelt cut a deal. He refrained from prosecuting some of the wealthiest men in America for treason. They agreed to end Wall Street's opposition to the New Deal.
We didn't prosecute treason then and we can't even impeach now. Between reading these two items and listening to the audiobook of Chalmers Johnson's Nemesis, I am beginning to understand why Richard Hofstadter had to write that essay of his.
I hope to write more about Johnson's book but I am not even halfway through it yet. But what disturbs me is, as he notes, that we have 700+ military installations of various ilks around the world and a total "defense" budget of somewhere near three quarters of a trillion dollars. And remember how Gen. Tommy Franks said that he didn't think the Constitution could survive another large-scale terrorist attack? James Madison said much which explains why there's that bit in the Third Amendment about quartering soldiers – it's about standing armies. A couple choice quotes:
Of all the enemies to public liberty war is, perhaps, the most to be dreaded, because it comprises and develops the germ of every other. War is the parent of armies; from these proceed debts and taxes; and armies, and debts, and taxes are the known instruments for bringing the many under the domination of the few. In war, too, the discretionary power of the Executive is extended; its influence in dealing out offices, honors, and emoluments is multiplied; and all the means of seducing the minds, are added to those of subduing the force, of the people.... [There is also an] inequality of fortunes, and the opportunities of fraud, growing out of a state of war, and ... degeneracy of manners and of morals.... No nation could preserve its freedom in the midst of continual warfare.
A standing military force, with an overgrown Executive will not long be safe companions to liberty. The means of defence agst. foreign danger, have been always the instruments of tyranny at home. Among the Romans it was a standing maxim to excite a war, whenever a revolt was apprehended. Throughout all Europe, the armies kept up under the pretext of defending, have enslaved the people.
I'm not paranoid but I do plead for eternal vigilance. Oliver Stone is bound to gain credibility again if this stuff keeps up.
17 August, 2007
Let Who Will Be Clever
Were my father still alive, he would have turned 70 today. Despite our rocky relationship, I find that I miss him. There are times when those days immediately after his death trapped in Louisiana at the mercy of Teamsters and the South's slow pace seem like just yesterday. Other times they seem so far away. The same goes for memories of my youth. On occasion it doesn’t feel like it was so long ago that my dad, then aged 49, took advantage of IBM's early retirement plan and said farewell to Chicago and the workaday world. While there are certainly things from this time that I often would rather forget, one thing my parents generally and my father specifically did that I cannot let loose from my mind was that they reinforced in me a notion that being smart is laudable and a love of learning, even for its own sake, is virtuous. I am, I think, reasonably smart but, if the latter is true, then I can stake a claim to a large chunk of virtue.
During my childhood, the old man was a voracious reader and, while his library wasn’t exceptionally voluminous, it was substantial in other ways. During the last few years of my father's life, he began giving his books to my brother and me. It seemed he was giving up on one of the great joys in his life. He always claimed that he couldn’t read any longer due to failing eyesight which I never understood. For one thing, his ocular problems were nothing that glasses couldn't correct and secondly, there are large print books available. Hell, there were audiobooks ready and waiting for him. He never took to them, however, and I saw him reading many a time even after he'd emptied out his library having pleaded bad vision. My father's library had more books on World War II than was probably safe and my brother caught the history bug early. Ergo, when my dad began dispensing books, those tomes ended up with him. I, on the other hand, got all 54 volumes of the Great Books of the Western World and its 10-volume introductory set.
Now, lest this post fall any deeper into overwrought sentimentality, I will say that I bring all of this up for a reason. It's my blog and my father has been on my mind but it's really a post at Dane101 that caught my attention and inspired all of this. The post is called "State GOP would tune out one of Wisconsin's greatest resources" by Jesse Russell. It's part encomium for Wisconsin Public Radio and part lament at the prospect of its loss. The potential budget cuts which would herald the end of WPR are explained by Bill Lueders of Isthmus here. It's part of a larger scheme by Republicans in the State Assembly to shortchange our public university system. WPR, along with WPT, the UW School of Workers, the UW-Madison Havens Center, and the Wisconsin Humanities Council are all satellites of the UW and are all looking at their funding drying up. Also on the financial chopping block is the UW Law School because Rep. Frank Lasee (R-Green Bay) thinks the state already has too many lawyers and they "excess" ones are filing too many frivolous lawsuits. I don't know that there are too many lawyers here in Wisconsin and, besides, why not take action against those who file frivolous lawsuits instead of beheading an institution of learning? All of this is part of a larger realm where our university system is held in low regard by various lawmakers. I've seen some of them on the WPT program Here and Now and their remarks always frame the UW as a financial drain. The Democrats on the program are only marginally better as they tend to take the opposite tact and advertise the UW as a generator of revenue with both sides being in opposition to our universities as institutions of learning. Why are the notions of an education having value beyond income and having an educated public so often ignored?
Reading Lueders' piece served to reinforce my preconceived notion that anti-intellectualism is prevalent here in Wisconsin and the country at-large. I first read John Erskine's "The Moral Obligation To Be Intelligent" when I was a teen and I found it in on my dad's bookshelf in one of the volumes of the introductory set to the GBotWW. In it, Erskine argues against our Anglo-Saxon inheritance where intelligence is equated with evil and for our Greek forbears who gave us "assurance that sin and misery are the fruit of ignorance and that to know is to achieve virtue". The former holds that "stupidity is first cousin to moral conduct" and I am severely tempted to assert that certain Republican assemblymen hold this dictum to be true or, at the very least, the folks who elected them do. This is not something which I can prove but my experience of living outside of Eau Claire for three and a half years does little to dissuade me. While the multiple teachers' strikes in Chicago when I lived there spawned animosity, I was not prepared for the derision poured upon teachers when I found myself a resident of Wisconsin. Saying that folks disliked teachers is like saying Packers fans dislike the Bears. For me, that most parents didn’t care one iota about education was obvious from the way kids on the sports teams were venerated while those of us on academic teams were ignored; it was apparent in the sheer ignorance of some of their kids and the pride that the kids took in it. I could go on for pages but let me just give two examples.
The first is a short ditty. I am a junior sitting in my American History class. The girl in the adjoining row asked me one day – in all earnestness – why we celebrate the 4th of July. My second example came when I was a senior and our physics class was grading the exams of the remedial physical science class. There was a question akin to "Gravity is: a) a breakfast cereal b) a model of a car c) a force which pulls objects to the ground". That's not verbatim but it was written in such a way that the right answer stood out from the rest. One guy got this wrong. He also left true/false questions blank. His writing looked like that of an 8-year old. And these weren't just the odd exceptions to an otherwise studious group of kids. While not the rule, these kinds of things happened very frequently.
It is tempting for me to conclude that, if most Wisconsin residents valued education instead of venerating athletes, we wouldn't be having these debates. But I'm reluctant to wholly endorse it. Americans tend to be ambivalent about learned folk. We are quick to cite the view of an expert's take on an issue if it suits our purpose. Unfortunately we are just as quick to denounce experts as being out of touch with reality when their views conflict with our own. UW philosophy professor Lester Hunt, however, has no problem with endorsing the view. In a post where he tossed around the idea of privatizing our university system, he commented:
On the other hand, state universities are supported by all the taxpayers, who are forced to do so. Many of them don't understand universities, don't give a damn about them, and in some cases would be hostile to the very idea, if it were correctly explained to them.
While it may be the case that the United States has always had an anti-intellectual bent, is seems that the situation has come to its apotheosis over the past few years. Christopher Hitchens observed that in 1800 "electors were offered a choice between the president of the American Philosophical Society and the founder of the American Academy of Arts and Sciences." Today we would be lucky have even the most junior member of any such organization as president. Such a person would, of course, be denounced from many quarters as an "elite", which is now a pejorative term. Todd Gitlin quotes Baynard R. Hall who wrote of the nascent state of Indiana in 1843: "We always preferred an ignorant bad man to a talented one, and hence attempts were usually made to ruin the moral character of a smart candidate; since unhappily smartness and wickedness were supposed to be generally coupled, and incompetence and goodness." The popular vote of the 2000 presidential election notwithstanding (and even it was a very close race), doesn't this still ring true today?
During my childhood, the old man was a voracious reader and, while his library wasn’t exceptionally voluminous, it was substantial in other ways. During the last few years of my father's life, he began giving his books to my brother and me. It seemed he was giving up on one of the great joys in his life. He always claimed that he couldn’t read any longer due to failing eyesight which I never understood. For one thing, his ocular problems were nothing that glasses couldn't correct and secondly, there are large print books available. Hell, there were audiobooks ready and waiting for him. He never took to them, however, and I saw him reading many a time even after he'd emptied out his library having pleaded bad vision. My father's library had more books on World War II than was probably safe and my brother caught the history bug early. Ergo, when my dad began dispensing books, those tomes ended up with him. I, on the other hand, got all 54 volumes of the Great Books of the Western World and its 10-volume introductory set.
Now, lest this post fall any deeper into overwrought sentimentality, I will say that I bring all of this up for a reason. It's my blog and my father has been on my mind but it's really a post at Dane101 that caught my attention and inspired all of this. The post is called "State GOP would tune out one of Wisconsin's greatest resources" by Jesse Russell. It's part encomium for Wisconsin Public Radio and part lament at the prospect of its loss. The potential budget cuts which would herald the end of WPR are explained by Bill Lueders of Isthmus here. It's part of a larger scheme by Republicans in the State Assembly to shortchange our public university system. WPR, along with WPT, the UW School of Workers, the UW-Madison Havens Center, and the Wisconsin Humanities Council are all satellites of the UW and are all looking at their funding drying up. Also on the financial chopping block is the UW Law School because Rep. Frank Lasee (R-Green Bay) thinks the state already has too many lawyers and they "excess" ones are filing too many frivolous lawsuits. I don't know that there are too many lawyers here in Wisconsin and, besides, why not take action against those who file frivolous lawsuits instead of beheading an institution of learning? All of this is part of a larger realm where our university system is held in low regard by various lawmakers. I've seen some of them on the WPT program Here and Now and their remarks always frame the UW as a financial drain. The Democrats on the program are only marginally better as they tend to take the opposite tact and advertise the UW as a generator of revenue with both sides being in opposition to our universities as institutions of learning. Why are the notions of an education having value beyond income and having an educated public so often ignored?
Reading Lueders' piece served to reinforce my preconceived notion that anti-intellectualism is prevalent here in Wisconsin and the country at-large. I first read John Erskine's "The Moral Obligation To Be Intelligent" when I was a teen and I found it in on my dad's bookshelf in one of the volumes of the introductory set to the GBotWW. In it, Erskine argues against our Anglo-Saxon inheritance where intelligence is equated with evil and for our Greek forbears who gave us "assurance that sin and misery are the fruit of ignorance and that to know is to achieve virtue". The former holds that "stupidity is first cousin to moral conduct" and I am severely tempted to assert that certain Republican assemblymen hold this dictum to be true or, at the very least, the folks who elected them do. This is not something which I can prove but my experience of living outside of Eau Claire for three and a half years does little to dissuade me. While the multiple teachers' strikes in Chicago when I lived there spawned animosity, I was not prepared for the derision poured upon teachers when I found myself a resident of Wisconsin. Saying that folks disliked teachers is like saying Packers fans dislike the Bears. For me, that most parents didn’t care one iota about education was obvious from the way kids on the sports teams were venerated while those of us on academic teams were ignored; it was apparent in the sheer ignorance of some of their kids and the pride that the kids took in it. I could go on for pages but let me just give two examples.
The first is a short ditty. I am a junior sitting in my American History class. The girl in the adjoining row asked me one day – in all earnestness – why we celebrate the 4th of July. My second example came when I was a senior and our physics class was grading the exams of the remedial physical science class. There was a question akin to "Gravity is: a) a breakfast cereal b) a model of a car c) a force which pulls objects to the ground". That's not verbatim but it was written in such a way that the right answer stood out from the rest. One guy got this wrong. He also left true/false questions blank. His writing looked like that of an 8-year old. And these weren't just the odd exceptions to an otherwise studious group of kids. While not the rule, these kinds of things happened very frequently.
It is tempting for me to conclude that, if most Wisconsin residents valued education instead of venerating athletes, we wouldn't be having these debates. But I'm reluctant to wholly endorse it. Americans tend to be ambivalent about learned folk. We are quick to cite the view of an expert's take on an issue if it suits our purpose. Unfortunately we are just as quick to denounce experts as being out of touch with reality when their views conflict with our own. UW philosophy professor Lester Hunt, however, has no problem with endorsing the view. In a post where he tossed around the idea of privatizing our university system, he commented:
On the other hand, state universities are supported by all the taxpayers, who are forced to do so. Many of them don't understand universities, don't give a damn about them, and in some cases would be hostile to the very idea, if it were correctly explained to them.
While it may be the case that the United States has always had an anti-intellectual bent, is seems that the situation has come to its apotheosis over the past few years. Christopher Hitchens observed that in 1800 "electors were offered a choice between the president of the American Philosophical Society and the founder of the American Academy of Arts and Sciences." Today we would be lucky have even the most junior member of any such organization as president. Such a person would, of course, be denounced from many quarters as an "elite", which is now a pejorative term. Todd Gitlin quotes Baynard R. Hall who wrote of the nascent state of Indiana in 1843: "We always preferred an ignorant bad man to a talented one, and hence attempts were usually made to ruin the moral character of a smart candidate; since unhappily smartness and wickedness were supposed to be generally coupled, and incompetence and goodness." The popular vote of the 2000 presidential election notwithstanding (and even it was a very close race), doesn't this still ring true today?
15 August, 2007
In Case You Don't Torrent
I introduced The Dulcinea to torrenting last night so there are obviously people out there who still don't know what it is. Anyway, if you are one these folks, then know that you can watch Richard Dawkins' latest TV program, The Enemies of Reason up at Google Video. (Thanks to P.Z. Myers for pointing this out.)
I've seen it and it's wonderful. While the program is unlikely to persuade people who read their horoscopes everyday and take it seriously, hopefully it can ignite conversations about Dawkins' assertion that mystics, seers, and the like contribute to a general ignorance amongst the population of science and a rejection of reason and logic. He quite rightly points out how people who believe in astrology, ESP, and the like are more than happy to take advantage of the fruits of science and reason when it suits them and to turn their backs when it doesn't. It says quite a bit on how the human psyche works. Here's the part about astrology:
You'd think people would have stopped allowing themselves to be in front of the camera with him by now.
I've seen it and it's wonderful. While the program is unlikely to persuade people who read their horoscopes everyday and take it seriously, hopefully it can ignite conversations about Dawkins' assertion that mystics, seers, and the like contribute to a general ignorance amongst the population of science and a rejection of reason and logic. He quite rightly points out how people who believe in astrology, ESP, and the like are more than happy to take advantage of the fruits of science and reason when it suits them and to turn their backs when it doesn't. It says quite a bit on how the human psyche works. Here's the part about astrology:
You'd think people would have stopped allowing themselves to be in front of the camera with him by now.
Polynya - Polynya
Luke Berchowitz is a former Madisonian now living in Chapel Hill, North Carolina. Together with Amelia, Andrea, Pat, and Thom, they comprise Polynya and their eponymous debut was released this summer. Any band naming themselves after a "non-linear area of open water surrounded by sea ice" has to be interesting. I suppose that the band inhabits the indie rock genre but I don't have any hip band names to drop in comparison. Instead I will offer that Polynya deconstruct the pop song and reassemble it after having tweaked a bit here or replaced another element altogether there. And they do it all under the guidance of a post-rock alchemist.
Take "Cubicle". It begins with a straight-ahead beat and jangly guitar ala REM but then a synthesizer pops up for a stint before some heavily processed vocals cut in. Of the five members of the band, four of them contribute their voices and they are put to good use on one of my favorite cuts from the album, "Tarantula". It has a relentlessly steady beat and plenty of harmony vocals, both male and female. With lines like, "I'm open to all things that come my way", the song has a very expansive feel. Then there's the fantastic guitar soloing in the second half of the tune. Imagine the Velvet Underground having done road music. There are certainly nods to 60s pop scattered about the album but perhaps nowhere so blatant as on "Without a Trace". It's got the organ sound of the time and the breezy nonchalance of the West Coast scene which gave us the Mamas and the Papas.
This is followed up by the more playful "Where Am I". All manner of sounds from guitars and keys churn away in the background while an almost dreamy accordion evokes the childhood fun to be had in the summertime. "Sweatshop" is one of the heavier songs and also more straightforward. With its gritty guitar, it's a piece of garage rock, albeit a bit twisted and with a bit of synthesizer instead of organ. At almost six minutes, "Islands" is the closest thing to an epic on the album. Amelia and Andrea take the vocal chores here and their voices echo into the distance over a landscape of slinky synths that would sound at home on an Ozric Tentacles album.
I'll admit that it took some time for Polynya to sink in. The songs may seem simple at first listen, but they're really intricate tapestries woven with care. Odd synth sounds pop up at the most appropriate moments along with a snippet of an unearthly sounding guitar or a bit of percussion. And, while most of the band sings at one point or another, Amelia and Andrea's voices are the stars. They can be more conventional as when shouting "Get to work now, this is for kids" in "Sweatshop" or take on a diaphanous quality as they do in "Islands".
Here's to hoping that Polynya start playing outside of Chapel Hill.
You Forgot a Couple
I was at Woodman's last night looking for unpasteurized beer to cook with and I realized that it's been ages since I've written about beer. There are lots of flavors out that have escaped mention here and I've got reviews of brews just lying around waiting to be typed up. But I do have some words about beer today.
So I missed the Great Taste of the Midwest and all the great beers to be found there. Luckily my counterpart at Dane101, Doug, was able to attend and he documented the whole thing here. Also at Dane101, editor Jesse Russell collected various impressions and recollections of the event and put them all in one place for easy reading.
The folks at Isthmus too got into the act with Robin Shepard's piece. Shepard even got the cover this week with "Beer Here!", a look at the area's breweries and brewpubs. Unfortunately the article is about as bland as a Budweiser but it does a yeoman's job of listing area breweries with an accompanying factoid or two. The assertion that Madison is a haven for quaffers is quite correct, though. We have a country ton of locally brewed beers to enjoy here in Madison. I am reminded of this every time I visit friends in Chicago who only have one brewery - Goose Island - in which to invest a little hometown pride. (And, in a bid for wider distribution, it sold part of itself to Anheuser-Busch.)
Being a beer lover myself, I appreciated Shepard's article and it being the cover story. However, there were a couple omissions. Berghoff-Huber was omitted. While Huber may not be a microbrewer's microbrewery, it's a regional that makes pretty good beer. I like to think of them as the Leinenkugel's of the southern half of Wisconsin. Huber and Huber Bock played a big role in my college days while Berghoff and Augsberger (I believe they owned the name at the time) were steps up from the usual swill when I couldn't afford Garten Brau, a.k.a. – Capital.
In the sidebar piece "Brewers without breweries", four companies whose beer is contract brewed by another brewery are mentioned – Cross Plains, Fauerbach, Hausmann, and Furthermore. How did Blucreek get left out? It's a small company here in Madison that has Sand Creek Brewing, I believe, up in Black River Falls brew their stuff. They have a fine AltBier and I like their Herbal Ale as well.
Whether these were omitted because of the author's tastes or perhaps constraints on space, I don't know. But they deserve to be a part of any look at the local brewing scene.
So I missed the Great Taste of the Midwest and all the great beers to be found there. Luckily my counterpart at Dane101, Doug, was able to attend and he documented the whole thing here. Also at Dane101, editor Jesse Russell collected various impressions and recollections of the event and put them all in one place for easy reading.
The folks at Isthmus too got into the act with Robin Shepard's piece. Shepard even got the cover this week with "Beer Here!", a look at the area's breweries and brewpubs. Unfortunately the article is about as bland as a Budweiser but it does a yeoman's job of listing area breweries with an accompanying factoid or two. The assertion that Madison is a haven for quaffers is quite correct, though. We have a country ton of locally brewed beers to enjoy here in Madison. I am reminded of this every time I visit friends in Chicago who only have one brewery - Goose Island - in which to invest a little hometown pride. (And, in a bid for wider distribution, it sold part of itself to Anheuser-Busch.)
Being a beer lover myself, I appreciated Shepard's article and it being the cover story. However, there were a couple omissions. Berghoff-Huber was omitted. While Huber may not be a microbrewer's microbrewery, it's a regional that makes pretty good beer. I like to think of them as the Leinenkugel's of the southern half of Wisconsin. Huber and Huber Bock played a big role in my college days while Berghoff and Augsberger (I believe they owned the name at the time) were steps up from the usual swill when I couldn't afford Garten Brau, a.k.a. – Capital.
In the sidebar piece "Brewers without breweries", four companies whose beer is contract brewed by another brewery are mentioned – Cross Plains, Fauerbach, Hausmann, and Furthermore. How did Blucreek get left out? It's a small company here in Madison that has Sand Creek Brewing, I believe, up in Black River Falls brew their stuff. They have a fine AltBier and I like their Herbal Ale as well.
Whether these were omitted because of the author's tastes or perhaps constraints on space, I don't know. But they deserve to be a part of any look at the local brewing scene.
Aspiring Ken Burns Documents The Bush
By way of the UW's Learning Support Services News blog, comes a video history of Madison's Greenbush neighborhood. It's available as a video podcast in 20 parts from the Center for the Study of Upper Midwest Culture.
At the same page is another podcast - Stories from Southwestern Wisconsin.
The CSUMC also had another podcast last spring which got off to a good start and then suddenly died. It was Wisconsin Englishes and was about the dialects of our fair state. I wrote about a presentation given on Wisconsin English last spring.
At the same page is another podcast - Stories from Southwestern Wisconsin.
The CSUMC also had another podcast last spring which got off to a good start and then suddenly died. It was Wisconsin Englishes and was about the dialects of our fair state. I wrote about a presentation given on Wisconsin English last spring.
14 August, 2007
Enemies of Reason Torrent Now Available
My mention of Richard Dawkins' new 2-part documentary, The Enemies of Reason has gotten a country ton of hits since I posted it 3 days ago. In fact, it's moved into #22 of my all-time most-viewed pages list.
Well, the torrent is now available. I'm seeding it as I type.
Well, the torrent is now available. I'm seeding it as I type.
13 August, 2007
Gringo Goes to Antojitos el Toril
After heading out from Lapacek's and vainly trying to find Eplegaarden, we then discovered it wasn't open anyway. So it was off to Antojitos el Toril for dinner. It had been a while since we'd eaten there and I was hungry as a lone apple just didn't cut it. I have written about it previously and am pleased to say that I still love the joint.
We started off with horchatas all around and were served some chips and salsas.

Our drinks proved a necessary palliative as the reddish-brown salsa is on the hot side. M. had put some on a chip but it proved too much for his 8-year old palate. I thought he was going to start balling but he braved the heat like a man.
Antojitos el Toril is an unassuming place. The furnishings are of a typical diner and there's the constant blare of the TV which alternated between a futbol match and a Mel Gibson movie dubbed into Spanish. There was a couple seated behind us and a gentleman sitting out in the other room in front of the counter. The guy was nursing a bottle of Corona while occasionally nodding off into siestaland. I think he had been out front with another gentleman putzing around with a motorcycle when we came in. I love AeT because it's not pretentious and foodies don't come here looking for a culinary experience as opposed to a meal. The joint is a restaurant and, while I don't exactly have my finger on the pulse of Madison's Latino community, it also seems to have become a hang-out.
Whenever I eat there, I am transported back to my youth and the home of my childhood friend Lalo Valdez. The Valdez family moved to Chicago when I was 5 or 6 and they lived across the alley and down the block from me. Mrs. V would make tortillas from scratch and the aromas from her kitchen were absolutely marvelous. She had 4 kids and a husband to feed so there was rarely a time when she didn't have something working on the stove. You could smell her cooking in the backyard. Mr. V was a great guy too. He put up with a bunch of little kids running around when he was trying to relax after work. Most evenings he sat at the kitchen table and ate pickled chili peppers. He would offer us punks a pepper to try and I remember well the first time I took him up on it. Man, I ran out the door screaming as Mr. V just laughed. And so, when I walk into Antojitos el Toril and I smell those aromas and I hear the Spanish being spoken, it really takes me back in time. It feels like home to me.
My waxing nostalgic aside, let's move onto the food. M got himself a chicken burrito.

I personally think that 8 is plenty old enough to grab a burrito in your hands and start gnawing on it. But M eschewed this approach and hacked at it with is fork turning it into mush. I tried a bit of the chicken filling after he had finished and it was tasty. The D had ordered pazole.

Pazole is a mild soup with pork and hominy that's seasoned with, amongst other things, chile. It was fantastic. With it comes a plate of fried tortillas, lime wedges, radish slices, and lettuce. After trying it, I longed for cooler weather when a hearty bowl of soup is the ultimate defense against the chill outside.
For my part, I went with the carnitas.

I'd had them there previously but I don't care. A plateful of pork is always a slice of heaven. While the meat was a bit dry, it was still pretty tasty. My horchata was soon drained as I had gleefully doused various sections of my plate with habanera hot sauce and got my mouth a-burnin'.
In a just world, there would be no Pedro's, Pasqual's, or Chipotle; Mexicali Rose would remain in the Dells to thrust its bland fare onto the unadventurous tourists; and one Tex Tubb's Taco Palace would be enough. But that's not the case. I cannot urge folks enough to check out Antojitos el Toril or any of the other small Mexican restaurants here in Madison where it's about good food and not about being seen or indulging in the blandest, most homogenized simulacrum of Mexican food that a focus group can imagine.
We started off with horchatas all around and were served some chips and salsas.
Our drinks proved a necessary palliative as the reddish-brown salsa is on the hot side. M. had put some on a chip but it proved too much for his 8-year old palate. I thought he was going to start balling but he braved the heat like a man.
Antojitos el Toril is an unassuming place. The furnishings are of a typical diner and there's the constant blare of the TV which alternated between a futbol match and a Mel Gibson movie dubbed into Spanish. There was a couple seated behind us and a gentleman sitting out in the other room in front of the counter. The guy was nursing a bottle of Corona while occasionally nodding off into siestaland. I think he had been out front with another gentleman putzing around with a motorcycle when we came in. I love AeT because it's not pretentious and foodies don't come here looking for a culinary experience as opposed to a meal. The joint is a restaurant and, while I don't exactly have my finger on the pulse of Madison's Latino community, it also seems to have become a hang-out.
Whenever I eat there, I am transported back to my youth and the home of my childhood friend Lalo Valdez. The Valdez family moved to Chicago when I was 5 or 6 and they lived across the alley and down the block from me. Mrs. V would make tortillas from scratch and the aromas from her kitchen were absolutely marvelous. She had 4 kids and a husband to feed so there was rarely a time when she didn't have something working on the stove. You could smell her cooking in the backyard. Mr. V was a great guy too. He put up with a bunch of little kids running around when he was trying to relax after work. Most evenings he sat at the kitchen table and ate pickled chili peppers. He would offer us punks a pepper to try and I remember well the first time I took him up on it. Man, I ran out the door screaming as Mr. V just laughed. And so, when I walk into Antojitos el Toril and I smell those aromas and I hear the Spanish being spoken, it really takes me back in time. It feels like home to me.
My waxing nostalgic aside, let's move onto the food. M got himself a chicken burrito.
I personally think that 8 is plenty old enough to grab a burrito in your hands and start gnawing on it. But M eschewed this approach and hacked at it with is fork turning it into mush. I tried a bit of the chicken filling after he had finished and it was tasty. The D had ordered pazole.
Pazole is a mild soup with pork and hominy that's seasoned with, amongst other things, chile. It was fantastic. With it comes a plate of fried tortillas, lime wedges, radish slices, and lettuce. After trying it, I longed for cooler weather when a hearty bowl of soup is the ultimate defense against the chill outside.
For my part, I went with the carnitas.
I'd had them there previously but I don't care. A plateful of pork is always a slice of heaven. While the meat was a bit dry, it was still pretty tasty. My horchata was soon drained as I had gleefully doused various sections of my plate with habanera hot sauce and got my mouth a-burnin'.
In a just world, there would be no Pedro's, Pasqual's, or Chipotle; Mexicali Rose would remain in the Dells to thrust its bland fare onto the unadventurous tourists; and one Tex Tubb's Taco Palace would be enough. But that's not the case. I cannot urge folks enough to check out Antojitos el Toril or any of the other small Mexican restaurants here in Madison where it's about good food and not about being seen or indulging in the blandest, most homogenized simulacrum of Mexican food that a focus group can imagine.
Let the Harvest Begin
I love August. Temperatures more to my liking won't being until next month but it's the beginning of harvest time. Corn is picked – the sweetest of the sweet. The kind of stuff you'd kill for during the long winter months when the corn you find tastes like wilted cardboard. You've got a small window on blueberries and you know fresh raspberries & cranberries will be coming your way anon. Squash is available and all manner of gourds ready themselves for your pleasure. I have been listening to an audiobook by Anthony Bourdain wherein he travels the world and eats. He goes to a few fancy restaurants but most of his tales are about hanging out with the salt of the earth. The biggest refrain of the book is the word "fresh". He says it a million times over the course of five CDs. Bourdain visits folks who live near their food sources so vegetables are picked that morning and a pig is slaughtered for dinner that night. Pursuant to this and a previous post of mine, The Dulcinea, M., and myself hopped in the car yesterday and zipped up to Poynette for a visit to Lapacek's Orchard.

We were greeted by a big, shaggy dog whose fur was filled with the detritus you get from living outside - dirt, leaves, and probably a few bugs. He didn't seem to mind, though. A woman, presumably Mrs. Lapacek, was walking towards us from the house behind us yelling at the dog. I think his name was Mitch, if memory serves. She needn't have worried because Mitch was very friendly and, as I rustled around the trunk, I extended a hand and scratched behind his ears. It was a beautiful day and the orchard was nestled in the gently rolling hills east of town. We wandered inside and, much to my dismay, discovered that it wasn't a pick-your-own joint. They had only been open a couple days and a mere handful of varieties were available as it was still early in the season. The proprietors were a young couple and, just like Mitch, both of them were extremely friendly. Mrs. Lapacek greeted us cheerfully a second time and almost immediately directed us to some baskets where we were given free samples. M got a William's Pride, The D a Paulared, and I ended up with a Zestar. Mein apfel war sehr scharf! Juicy, tart, and just plain tasty. The Paulared was much sweeter. A bag of them was $3.50 but the Zestars were twice as much. They're very popular and go quickly, we were told. Mrs. L was very helpful and offered suggestions to match varieties to how it was going to be eaten. "These are good for eating," she said, "while these are great for applesauce." My mind kept getting distracted with visions of my kitchen where I stood there rolling out dough for apple pies and watching as my apple fritter batter rose from the ale I had put into it.
There was also some corn for sale as well as several flavors of chilies, squash, and some of the finest looking red onions you'll ever lay your eyes on. These puppies were big and shiny and I knew that there were tomatoes and chilies in our garden just waiting to meet that onion in a big bowl of pico de gallo where the marriage of their flavors could be consummated. An adjoining room had gifts such as clothing, jewelry, and bric-Ã -brac of all sorts. Through a set of glass doors in the back was the apple sorting room with Mr. L and another older gentleman who were at work. They were being helped by someone you'll see in a moment. Through a window next to them some curious-looking heads bobbed and weaved in and out of view. What were these creatures?

They had emus! Two of them.


I don't have a good photo of their feet but they were enormously long with vicious-looking claws. Best not to get into a dust-up with one of these birds. They poked their heads through the bars of the fence and generally just looked around at the strange creatures before them. M occasionally walked perilously close to the fence and I readied my camera for a Fox-like When Emus Attack! moment. Alas, it never arrived.
Back inside, I asked the Mrs. L about the Wolf River apples that I had read about. "Do they really get to be a pound apiece?" I asked eagerly. "Are the legends of one apple per pie really true?" Indeed they were, she assured me. In fact, she seemed slightly surprised that I had never heard of them before. They would be ready around the 15th of next month as would other varieties, cider, and, if memory serves, some cows to distract the attention of the kids. The older gentleman wandered in from the sorting room and I chatted him up a bit as well. These people knew apples and I was extremely jealous because I am woefully ignorant of them but I'm slowly learning. (I wonder what the older hippies types at the Willy Street Co-op would think if they found out that some of their favorite apples weren't around when Johnny Appleseed was doing his thing. Instead they might just be biting into an apple developed across the Mississippi at the University of Minnesota during their lifetimes.) I was also shown to a sign-up sheet for their electronic mailing list so I gleefully have them my e-mail addy. In about a month my inbox will have a message stating that Wolf River apples are available and I'll be trekking north once more.
Before we left with bags of apples, an onion, some chili relish from a place in Baraboo with the delightful prog rock name Hawkwind, and a couple other odds and ends, I grabbed this photo:

That's the youngest Lapacek. She was interminably cute sitting there watch her father sort apples as the emus peered in through the windows with Mitch resting on the cool concrete floor.
Despite not having been able to pick some myself, the trip was well worth it. The proprietors were extremely friendly, I got to see some emus, and then drive away with a bounty.
The Lapaceks reminded me of that Frontline documentary The Farmer's Wife. Agriculture is Wisconsin's biggest industry and politicos have been on the television talking about ag bills and farm subsidies lately. Listening to Herb Kohl talk is annoying enough but it's made worse when you come away not knowing anything more than you did when you started. I recently watched an interview with him and came away no smarter when it came to farm bills than I was before watching it. They're still a mystery to me. There's a lot of talk about saving family farms but it's all-too rare to actually hear the farmers themselves saying it. I am totally in favor of helping family farms and preventing their lands from becoming subdivisions. And so it was just nice to actually go to a family farm and meet the folks who live and work there. Yet I am forced to wonder if Lapacek's Orchard will still be around when that little girl grows up.
We were greeted by a big, shaggy dog whose fur was filled with the detritus you get from living outside - dirt, leaves, and probably a few bugs. He didn't seem to mind, though. A woman, presumably Mrs. Lapacek, was walking towards us from the house behind us yelling at the dog. I think his name was Mitch, if memory serves. She needn't have worried because Mitch was very friendly and, as I rustled around the trunk, I extended a hand and scratched behind his ears. It was a beautiful day and the orchard was nestled in the gently rolling hills east of town. We wandered inside and, much to my dismay, discovered that it wasn't a pick-your-own joint. They had only been open a couple days and a mere handful of varieties were available as it was still early in the season. The proprietors were a young couple and, just like Mitch, both of them were extremely friendly. Mrs. Lapacek greeted us cheerfully a second time and almost immediately directed us to some baskets where we were given free samples. M got a William's Pride, The D a Paulared, and I ended up with a Zestar. Mein apfel war sehr scharf! Juicy, tart, and just plain tasty. The Paulared was much sweeter. A bag of them was $3.50 but the Zestars were twice as much. They're very popular and go quickly, we were told. Mrs. L was very helpful and offered suggestions to match varieties to how it was going to be eaten. "These are good for eating," she said, "while these are great for applesauce." My mind kept getting distracted with visions of my kitchen where I stood there rolling out dough for apple pies and watching as my apple fritter batter rose from the ale I had put into it.
There was also some corn for sale as well as several flavors of chilies, squash, and some of the finest looking red onions you'll ever lay your eyes on. These puppies were big and shiny and I knew that there were tomatoes and chilies in our garden just waiting to meet that onion in a big bowl of pico de gallo where the marriage of their flavors could be consummated. An adjoining room had gifts such as clothing, jewelry, and bric-Ã -brac of all sorts. Through a set of glass doors in the back was the apple sorting room with Mr. L and another older gentleman who were at work. They were being helped by someone you'll see in a moment. Through a window next to them some curious-looking heads bobbed and weaved in and out of view. What were these creatures?
They had emus! Two of them.
I don't have a good photo of their feet but they were enormously long with vicious-looking claws. Best not to get into a dust-up with one of these birds. They poked their heads through the bars of the fence and generally just looked around at the strange creatures before them. M occasionally walked perilously close to the fence and I readied my camera for a Fox-like When Emus Attack! moment. Alas, it never arrived.
Back inside, I asked the Mrs. L about the Wolf River apples that I had read about. "Do they really get to be a pound apiece?" I asked eagerly. "Are the legends of one apple per pie really true?" Indeed they were, she assured me. In fact, she seemed slightly surprised that I had never heard of them before. They would be ready around the 15th of next month as would other varieties, cider, and, if memory serves, some cows to distract the attention of the kids. The older gentleman wandered in from the sorting room and I chatted him up a bit as well. These people knew apples and I was extremely jealous because I am woefully ignorant of them but I'm slowly learning. (I wonder what the older hippies types at the Willy Street Co-op would think if they found out that some of their favorite apples weren't around when Johnny Appleseed was doing his thing. Instead they might just be biting into an apple developed across the Mississippi at the University of Minnesota during their lifetimes.) I was also shown to a sign-up sheet for their electronic mailing list so I gleefully have them my e-mail addy. In about a month my inbox will have a message stating that Wolf River apples are available and I'll be trekking north once more.
Before we left with bags of apples, an onion, some chili relish from a place in Baraboo with the delightful prog rock name Hawkwind, and a couple other odds and ends, I grabbed this photo:
That's the youngest Lapacek. She was interminably cute sitting there watch her father sort apples as the emus peered in through the windows with Mitch resting on the cool concrete floor.
Despite not having been able to pick some myself, the trip was well worth it. The proprietors were extremely friendly, I got to see some emus, and then drive away with a bounty.
The Lapaceks reminded me of that Frontline documentary The Farmer's Wife. Agriculture is Wisconsin's biggest industry and politicos have been on the television talking about ag bills and farm subsidies lately. Listening to Herb Kohl talk is annoying enough but it's made worse when you come away not knowing anything more than you did when you started. I recently watched an interview with him and came away no smarter when it came to farm bills than I was before watching it. They're still a mystery to me. There's a lot of talk about saving family farms but it's all-too rare to actually hear the farmers themselves saying it. I am totally in favor of helping family farms and preventing their lands from becoming subdivisions. And so it was just nice to actually go to a family farm and meet the folks who live and work there. Yet I am forced to wonder if Lapacek's Orchard will still be around when that little girl grows up.
11 August, 2007
At the Sinny - Rescue Dawn
Last night I took my friend Pete to see Werner Herzog's latest film, Resuce Dawn. When he came over to my house, I was pleased to discover that he'd finally taken my advice and rented Incident at Loch Ness, a hilarious send-up of Herzog, his obsessions, and his relationship with Klaus Kinski. Pete and I have similar tastes in film, though they diverge at times. But when a Kurosawa film is making the rounds again or when there's a new Herzog film to be had, you can bet your life we'll be seen in a theatre together. We had gone to Herzog's Grizzly Man together and now it was once again time to honor our ritual.

Christian Bale plays Dieter Dengler, the German immigrant turned pilot who is shot down in 1966 over Laos. Bale may not have the onscreen presence of Kinski, but his more subtle decent into mental crisis is no less harrowing. The film begins aboard an aircraft carrier with the pilots being informed of their top secret mission to hit targets in Laos. This scene with the guys in their flight suits listening to their commanding officer certainly brought Top Gun to mind. But this association serves as misdirection as any rah-rah go-America jingoism dissipates. It isn't long before the first sortie is airborne and Dengler finds himself shot down just as quickly. The shot of Dengler scrambling into the woods as he is pursued is a wonderful long shot of the downed plane burning in a beautiful field of tall grass and dwarfed by the mountains. You begin to feel things shifting as nature closes in when you see Dengler's tiny figure being swallowed by the grass. In another scene, he stands on a high rocky protuberance hoping to catch sight of a rescue plane. This picture of a solitary figure set against a vast natural backdrop is pure Herzog.

He is captured and eventually brought before the provincial governor (played by François Chau who LOST fans will recognize as the star of the DHARMA orientation films) who asks him to sign a confessional statement renouncing his and the U.S. government's actions. He refuses citing his love of country – "I love America because America gave me wings." A P.O.W. camp becomes his home and there Dengler meets a helicopter pilot named Duane, played by Steve Zahn, and Gene from Eugene, a contractor masterfully portrayed by Jeremy Davies. Along with them are other non-Americans who, along with Gene and Duane, were part of Air America. After two years of internment, they have long hair, beards, and bicker amongst themselves like an old married couple. Scraggily yet loveable.
Their captors range from the brutal man nicknamed Little Hitler to another man who is a dwarf and given the playful moniker of Jumbo. Jumbo is fairly kind to the prisoners and unknowingly abets them in their bid to escape. Dengler is slowly revealed to be something less than the all-American persona we've witnessed thus far. His headstrong desire to escape and maintain a positive attitude at the prospects are at the fore but there are little things that clue you in to what's really happening inside his mind. Hints of mania alternate with a sense of earnestness that just isn't normal and this gentle unraveling is testament to Bale's acting ability.
Things really get moving when the prisoners escape with Dengler and Duane heading off by themselves into a classic Herzogland. The jungle is unremitting in its indifference to their plight. They peacefully float down a river and only escape being hurled over a waterfall at the last minute only to find their momentary relief tempered by the need to remove leeches from their skin. Our heroes find an abandoned village and take up residence. U.S. helicopters are heard in the distance but no amount of waving and screaming garners their attention so Dengler sets the village on fire. This gets the attention of those in the helicopters but, instead of rescue, they open fire on Dengler as he desperately flails his arms in the air. The defiant pair is now looking more ragged than ever and futility seems to have set in. One last bit of hope rises as they stumble upon a small village but are accosted by machete-wielding villagers. Dengler and Duane are on bended knees begging for help in what is probably the film's most intense scene.

Dengler, reduced to eating a snake raw, finally finds rescue. He is shuffled off to a military hospital where he recuperates. There's a little light humor here as he is kidnapped by his comrades and brought back to his carrier. The feel-good homecoming is perhaps a bit too Hollywood but Herzog pokes some holes in it. When asked, "Was it your faith in God and country that kept you going?", Dengler remains silent "You have to believe in something," intones his interlocutor. When he finally does manage a reply, it is "I believe I need a steak". His fellow crewmember won't let up and solicits advice to which he is given the cryptic "Empty that which is full. Fill that which is empty. If it itches, scratch it.".
While it is tempting to cast Rescue Dawn as Herzog-lite, the film is really the obsessive Werner Herzog we all know and love. There may be recognizable American faces and a "happy" ending, but every bit of "standard" storytelling is tempered by the director's obsession with turning madness into a virtue when a person is confronted by the cold disinterest of the universe. Rescue Dawn is bookended by scenes that veer a bit too close to cliché but at least you can see in them elements beneath the surface which belie the typical Hollywood spiel. The protagonist has been inalterably changed and not necessarily for the better. As for the meat of the movie, it is classic Herzog. Nature is cruel and uncaring and, when faced with this inexorable fact of life, Dengler can only retreat towards primal instinct while his humanity fades to madness. Jeremy Davies deserves great credit as Gene. Duane is able to muster the strength to carry on with Dengler's help. Gene, however, never really had any strength to begin with. When we first meet him, he's already lost it. It's like when we're introduced to Dennis Hopper's character in Apocalypse Now for the first time. Gene got pushed to the edge a long time ago and only a shell remains. In a way, the 3 lead characters all present gradations of the process of losing it with Dengler and Gene being at either side.
Peter Zeitlinger's cinematography captures the beauty of the locations to great effect while never letting us forget that it's the characters that are centerstage. It's the posture of their emaciated bodies set against a backdrop which is important along with capturing the looks in their eyes. I also greatly appreciated the judicious use of music in the film. The score by Klaus Badelt was notable for the times when it was absent, such as the chase scene immediately after Dengler's plane crashes, as well as the times when it's a slow burn that broods over the psyches of the characters. The band Popol Vuh has contributed to the soundtracks of many Herzog films and they are found here too.
Apocalypse Now also featured a decent into madness during the Vietnam War but Herzog's vision here is less grandiose and surreal and more intimate and realistic. Perhaps the Conquistador of the Useless has streamlined things and no longer feels the need to really haul a steamship across mountains for the camera. (And maybe the off-screen tensions have eased as well.) But Herzog still feels obliged to explore how people move steamships inside their heads and it is still compelling cinema.
Christian Bale plays Dieter Dengler, the German immigrant turned pilot who is shot down in 1966 over Laos. Bale may not have the onscreen presence of Kinski, but his more subtle decent into mental crisis is no less harrowing. The film begins aboard an aircraft carrier with the pilots being informed of their top secret mission to hit targets in Laos. This scene with the guys in their flight suits listening to their commanding officer certainly brought Top Gun to mind. But this association serves as misdirection as any rah-rah go-America jingoism dissipates. It isn't long before the first sortie is airborne and Dengler finds himself shot down just as quickly. The shot of Dengler scrambling into the woods as he is pursued is a wonderful long shot of the downed plane burning in a beautiful field of tall grass and dwarfed by the mountains. You begin to feel things shifting as nature closes in when you see Dengler's tiny figure being swallowed by the grass. In another scene, he stands on a high rocky protuberance hoping to catch sight of a rescue plane. This picture of a solitary figure set against a vast natural backdrop is pure Herzog.
He is captured and eventually brought before the provincial governor (played by François Chau who LOST fans will recognize as the star of the DHARMA orientation films) who asks him to sign a confessional statement renouncing his and the U.S. government's actions. He refuses citing his love of country – "I love America because America gave me wings." A P.O.W. camp becomes his home and there Dengler meets a helicopter pilot named Duane, played by Steve Zahn, and Gene from Eugene, a contractor masterfully portrayed by Jeremy Davies. Along with them are other non-Americans who, along with Gene and Duane, were part of Air America. After two years of internment, they have long hair, beards, and bicker amongst themselves like an old married couple. Scraggily yet loveable.
Their captors range from the brutal man nicknamed Little Hitler to another man who is a dwarf and given the playful moniker of Jumbo. Jumbo is fairly kind to the prisoners and unknowingly abets them in their bid to escape. Dengler is slowly revealed to be something less than the all-American persona we've witnessed thus far. His headstrong desire to escape and maintain a positive attitude at the prospects are at the fore but there are little things that clue you in to what's really happening inside his mind. Hints of mania alternate with a sense of earnestness that just isn't normal and this gentle unraveling is testament to Bale's acting ability.
Things really get moving when the prisoners escape with Dengler and Duane heading off by themselves into a classic Herzogland. The jungle is unremitting in its indifference to their plight. They peacefully float down a river and only escape being hurled over a waterfall at the last minute only to find their momentary relief tempered by the need to remove leeches from their skin. Our heroes find an abandoned village and take up residence. U.S. helicopters are heard in the distance but no amount of waving and screaming garners their attention so Dengler sets the village on fire. This gets the attention of those in the helicopters but, instead of rescue, they open fire on Dengler as he desperately flails his arms in the air. The defiant pair is now looking more ragged than ever and futility seems to have set in. One last bit of hope rises as they stumble upon a small village but are accosted by machete-wielding villagers. Dengler and Duane are on bended knees begging for help in what is probably the film's most intense scene.
Dengler, reduced to eating a snake raw, finally finds rescue. He is shuffled off to a military hospital where he recuperates. There's a little light humor here as he is kidnapped by his comrades and brought back to his carrier. The feel-good homecoming is perhaps a bit too Hollywood but Herzog pokes some holes in it. When asked, "Was it your faith in God and country that kept you going?", Dengler remains silent "You have to believe in something," intones his interlocutor. When he finally does manage a reply, it is "I believe I need a steak". His fellow crewmember won't let up and solicits advice to which he is given the cryptic "Empty that which is full. Fill that which is empty. If it itches, scratch it.".
While it is tempting to cast Rescue Dawn as Herzog-lite, the film is really the obsessive Werner Herzog we all know and love. There may be recognizable American faces and a "happy" ending, but every bit of "standard" storytelling is tempered by the director's obsession with turning madness into a virtue when a person is confronted by the cold disinterest of the universe. Rescue Dawn is bookended by scenes that veer a bit too close to cliché but at least you can see in them elements beneath the surface which belie the typical Hollywood spiel. The protagonist has been inalterably changed and not necessarily for the better. As for the meat of the movie, it is classic Herzog. Nature is cruel and uncaring and, when faced with this inexorable fact of life, Dengler can only retreat towards primal instinct while his humanity fades to madness. Jeremy Davies deserves great credit as Gene. Duane is able to muster the strength to carry on with Dengler's help. Gene, however, never really had any strength to begin with. When we first meet him, he's already lost it. It's like when we're introduced to Dennis Hopper's character in Apocalypse Now for the first time. Gene got pushed to the edge a long time ago and only a shell remains. In a way, the 3 lead characters all present gradations of the process of losing it with Dengler and Gene being at either side.
Peter Zeitlinger's cinematography captures the beauty of the locations to great effect while never letting us forget that it's the characters that are centerstage. It's the posture of their emaciated bodies set against a backdrop which is important along with capturing the looks in their eyes. I also greatly appreciated the judicious use of music in the film. The score by Klaus Badelt was notable for the times when it was absent, such as the chase scene immediately after Dengler's plane crashes, as well as the times when it's a slow burn that broods over the psyches of the characters. The band Popol Vuh has contributed to the soundtracks of many Herzog films and they are found here too.
Apocalypse Now also featured a decent into madness during the Vietnam War but Herzog's vision here is less grandiose and surreal and more intimate and realistic. Perhaps the Conquistador of the Useless has streamlined things and no longer feels the need to really haul a steamship across mountains for the camera. (And maybe the off-screen tensions have eased as well.) But Herzog still feels obliged to explore how people move steamships inside their heads and it is still compelling cinema.
Enemies of Reason
I recently wrote about such folks and now those of us here in the States should get their torrent clients ready as Richard Dawkins has a new TV show ready to air - The Enemies of Reason:
Is it rational that the dead can communicate with the living and give sound advice on how they should live their lives? What about sticking pins into your body to free the flow of Chi energy and cure your illness? Or the bending of spoons using your mind alone? Is that rational? Richard Dawkins doesn’t think so, and feels it is his duty to expose those areas of belief that exist without scientific proof, yet manage to hold the nation under their spell. He will take on the world’s leading proponents in their field of expertise, meet the victims who have used them and expose the history of the movements – from the charlatans who have milked these practices to the experiments and testing that have failed to produce conclusive results.
It airs on Monday in the UK so, by the time you get home from work that day, it should be available for download.
The Times had a write-up of the show and the following scene sounds amusing.
When Dawkins consulted a medium who has appeared on daytime television and charges £50 for instant phone readings she said she could hear or see his father “on the other side”.
He did his best not to look surprised as she continued: “I’m aware of your father stood right behind you. “On a spiritual level he wasn’t the most openest man with his thoughts and his feelings. Ummm, I kind of want to say that I do love you and I do care – but that wouldn’t have been his character.” (Or that of many middle-class father figures of his generation, a sceptic might have said.)
But Dawkins let her continue. “I’m aware that you don’t have you dad’s photograph out” – it was true, he didn’t – “so I’m a little bit concerned why. So I’m going to ask you: why don’t you have it out?” Dawkins had a bombshell ready: “Well, he might be aware that I don’t have it out because he comes to the house about once a week.” “Oh, he’s still here,” she said, adding after a few seconds: “I don’t feel it’s working.”
“Is that because you thought my father is dead and discovered that he’s still alive?”
“No, nothing to do with that. I don’t know.”
She commented later: “As a clairvoyant you’re only as good as the client.”
Is it rational that the dead can communicate with the living and give sound advice on how they should live their lives? What about sticking pins into your body to free the flow of Chi energy and cure your illness? Or the bending of spoons using your mind alone? Is that rational? Richard Dawkins doesn’t think so, and feels it is his duty to expose those areas of belief that exist without scientific proof, yet manage to hold the nation under their spell. He will take on the world’s leading proponents in their field of expertise, meet the victims who have used them and expose the history of the movements – from the charlatans who have milked these practices to the experiments and testing that have failed to produce conclusive results.
It airs on Monday in the UK so, by the time you get home from work that day, it should be available for download.
The Times had a write-up of the show and the following scene sounds amusing.
When Dawkins consulted a medium who has appeared on daytime television and charges £50 for instant phone readings she said she could hear or see his father “on the other side”.
He did his best not to look surprised as she continued: “I’m aware of your father stood right behind you. “On a spiritual level he wasn’t the most openest man with his thoughts and his feelings. Ummm, I kind of want to say that I do love you and I do care – but that wouldn’t have been his character.” (Or that of many middle-class father figures of his generation, a sceptic might have said.)
But Dawkins let her continue. “I’m aware that you don’t have you dad’s photograph out” – it was true, he didn’t – “so I’m a little bit concerned why. So I’m going to ask you: why don’t you have it out?” Dawkins had a bombshell ready: “Well, he might be aware that I don’t have it out because he comes to the house about once a week.” “Oh, he’s still here,” she said, adding after a few seconds: “I don’t feel it’s working.”
“Is that because you thought my father is dead and discovered that he’s still alive?”
“No, nothing to do with that. I don’t know.”
She commented later: “As a clairvoyant you’re only as good as the client.”
10 August, 2007
Deutsch and Español at the Sinny
When was the last time there were so many films by Germans here in Madison? (Not counting festivals, mind you.) Die Große Stille (Into Great Silence) has returned to Sundance where it is accompanied by Werner Herzog's Rescue Dawn. I may be seeing Herzog's latest this evening with a friend whose birthday was earlier this week. Rob Thomas of The Capital Times interviewed Herzog recently and you can read what he had to say here. To complete this Teutonic trifecta is Das Leben Der Anderen (The Lives of Others) over at the cheap seats of Market Square.
Sean over at Dane101 has the movie round-up for the week so I won't repeat much of what he said. However, I do want to mention the Found Footage Festival which is at the Orpheum tonight and that sci-fi/fantasy/Neil Gaiman types will be pleased to know that Stardust opens today.
One thing Sean neglected to mention was that Westgate will be showing Pirates of the Caribbean 3 with Spanish subtitles and Spider-Man 3 dubbed in Spanish and with English subtitles. (Why the subtitles?) I don't know how many Latinos read Dane101 but I think it deserved a mention as they're part of our community as well. Anyway, I'm unsure if the folks at Westgate are feeling the pinch from Sundance or whether it's just business as usual in trying to enter a different market. I'm hoping The Dulcinea, who is learning Spanish, will take me to one of the showings. She can learn a new language and I'll get to see a film for free.
The Latino community in Madison seems to really be making its presence felt. Shops & restaurants, a Spanish-language radio station and publications, films in Spanish or with Spanish subtitles, and it has apparently wrestled Hispanic Fest from politically correct hands and made it their own. With the ubiquity of cable, Madison is spared that period when Spanish language channels sprout up with all those cheesy soap operas. Unfortunately, I'm still waiting for the Wisconsin Los Lobos to appear. I want to hear a band which mixes norteño with polka, blues, and rock.
If Jesse Russell is reading this – have you considered finding someone to write at Dane101 in Spanish for the Latino community?
Sean over at Dane101 has the movie round-up for the week so I won't repeat much of what he said. However, I do want to mention the Found Footage Festival which is at the Orpheum tonight and that sci-fi/fantasy/Neil Gaiman types will be pleased to know that Stardust opens today.
One thing Sean neglected to mention was that Westgate will be showing Pirates of the Caribbean 3 with Spanish subtitles and Spider-Man 3 dubbed in Spanish and with English subtitles. (Why the subtitles?) I don't know how many Latinos read Dane101 but I think it deserved a mention as they're part of our community as well. Anyway, I'm unsure if the folks at Westgate are feeling the pinch from Sundance or whether it's just business as usual in trying to enter a different market. I'm hoping The Dulcinea, who is learning Spanish, will take me to one of the showings. She can learn a new language and I'll get to see a film for free.
The Latino community in Madison seems to really be making its presence felt. Shops & restaurants, a Spanish-language radio station and publications, films in Spanish or with Spanish subtitles, and it has apparently wrestled Hispanic Fest from politically correct hands and made it their own. With the ubiquity of cable, Madison is spared that period when Spanish language channels sprout up with all those cheesy soap operas. Unfortunately, I'm still waiting for the Wisconsin Los Lobos to appear. I want to hear a band which mixes norteño with polka, blues, and rock.
If Jesse Russell is reading this – have you considered finding someone to write at Dane101 in Spanish for the Latino community?
09 August, 2007
No Allowance For the Other
A couple weeks ago The Dulcinea and I headed downtown to hear Matt Rothschild speak about his new book, You Have No Rights: Stories of America in an Age of Repression.

Rothschild is the editor of the magazine The Progressive which is located right here in Madison. The room at The Overture Center was sparsely populated at first but filled up at 7:30 approached. Allen Ruff from Rainbow Bookstore was there selling copies of You Have No Rights as the crowd found its way to their seats. There were people young and old but mostly old. This disparity in the ages of the attendees is common from my experience. There is a healthy smattering of senior citizens who want to go to their graves informed and involved. The majority of the audience were middle-aged folks – people who probably rioted here at the UW against the Vietnam War. They have been political since their college years and continue to be so. The paucity of younger adults, however, was striking. There was a handful there scattered as they were around the room. You'd think the people that are going to toil under the effects of the government policies & decisions of the last six years the longest would have a keen interest. Perhaps this is because Rothschild just doesn't have the reputation and movie star charisma of a Michael Moore.

My observation aside, I personally enjoy hearing Rothschild speak immensely. He and I are in agreement politically most of the time and he is a godless heathen like myself. In fact, I enjoy Rothschild's work so much that The Dulcinea has taken to referring to him as my boyfriend. His book is basically a best-of compilation of stories from his "McCarthyism Watch" column which collects stories of civil rights abrogations. I've only glanced at the book and don't have it with me but Marc Eisen of Isthmus wrote a piece in anticipation of the event and listed a few of the 82 stories in the book. To wit:
* Stephen Downs being arrested for trespassing at the mall when he wears a tee shirt that says "Peace on Earth" on one side and "Give Peace a Chance" on the other.
* Laura Berg, a nurse at an Albuquerque veterans hospital, being investigated and accused of sedition by the Veterans Administration after she writes a letter to the editor accusing the Bush administration of criminal negligence for its Iraqi war.
* Frank Van Den Bosch of Platteville being arrested for disorderly conduct when he unfurls a sign saying "FUGW" when the Bush campaign caravan rolls through town.
* U.S. rowing champion Aquil Abdullah being repeatedly detained, questioned and searched at airports because he happens to be a black man with a Muslim-sounding name.
* Members of Peace Action Milwaukee being barred from flying to a demonstration against the School of the Americas because some of their names pop up on the mysterious law-enforcement "watch list."
There's also the story of Renee Jensen in West Virginia who put a sign up in her yard reading "Mr. Bush: You're fired". This prompted a visit by the Secret Service. Or take Marc Schultz who was reported to the FBI because he stood in a line at a coffee shop reading an article critical of Fox News.
It's hardly surprising that people trying to exercise their right of free speech at, say, a Bush rally are arrested. But what is surprising to me and even more profoundly disturbing are stories like Mr. Schultz's. It's one thing for a guy donning a black trench coat and sunglasses to bully people with slogans on t-shirts – those in power like to bully those who are not. But it's absolutely chilling to read about someone being reported to the authorities by a member of their community. What must be going through your mind to call the police or the FBI when you see someone in line for a latte reading criticism of Fox News? Who did this? How did this person feel threatened?
When John Nichols of The Cap Times editorialized in favor of the book, it elicited comments which basically said that, because Rothschild was allowed to publish the book and not get sent to Gitmo, then there's no problem. Either the most extreme bad thing happens or all is well with no middle ground, no shades of gray pointing in one direction or the other. How does one acquire this mindset?
Just as Bill Lueders published his account of being on-air with Ann Althouse, I was finishing up listening to the audiobook of John Dean's Concervatives Without Conscience. In it, Dean examines the history of conservatism in this country and contrasts his Goldwater conservatism with the flavor(s) now prevailing here. He uses the research of Bob Altemeyer, specifically his research into right-wing authoritarianism. Both the negative comments directed at Nichols and Althouse's incredulity that someone would actually want to wait for evidence seemed to me authoritarian in nature – both submission and aggression. Likewise for some of the examples in Rothschild's book. 9/11 induced fear into people and the Bush administration stepped up as a father figure, of sorts, to allay those fears. Authoritarian types will tend to go along with whatever the Bush administration says because it is attempting to do away with certain fears. And they heap derision on those who would be critical of the father figure.
I am certainly not giving Dean nor Altemeyer their due and I highly recommend reading their works. It is difficult for me to read the incidents in You Have No Rights and not think that authoritarian figures are at work.
Rothschild is the editor of the magazine The Progressive which is located right here in Madison. The room at The Overture Center was sparsely populated at first but filled up at 7:30 approached. Allen Ruff from Rainbow Bookstore was there selling copies of You Have No Rights as the crowd found its way to their seats. There were people young and old but mostly old. This disparity in the ages of the attendees is common from my experience. There is a healthy smattering of senior citizens who want to go to their graves informed and involved. The majority of the audience were middle-aged folks – people who probably rioted here at the UW against the Vietnam War. They have been political since their college years and continue to be so. The paucity of younger adults, however, was striking. There was a handful there scattered as they were around the room. You'd think the people that are going to toil under the effects of the government policies & decisions of the last six years the longest would have a keen interest. Perhaps this is because Rothschild just doesn't have the reputation and movie star charisma of a Michael Moore.
My observation aside, I personally enjoy hearing Rothschild speak immensely. He and I are in agreement politically most of the time and he is a godless heathen like myself. In fact, I enjoy Rothschild's work so much that The Dulcinea has taken to referring to him as my boyfriend. His book is basically a best-of compilation of stories from his "McCarthyism Watch" column which collects stories of civil rights abrogations. I've only glanced at the book and don't have it with me but Marc Eisen of Isthmus wrote a piece in anticipation of the event and listed a few of the 82 stories in the book. To wit:
* Stephen Downs being arrested for trespassing at the mall when he wears a tee shirt that says "Peace on Earth" on one side and "Give Peace a Chance" on the other.
* Laura Berg, a nurse at an Albuquerque veterans hospital, being investigated and accused of sedition by the Veterans Administration after she writes a letter to the editor accusing the Bush administration of criminal negligence for its Iraqi war.
* Frank Van Den Bosch of Platteville being arrested for disorderly conduct when he unfurls a sign saying "FUGW" when the Bush campaign caravan rolls through town.
* U.S. rowing champion Aquil Abdullah being repeatedly detained, questioned and searched at airports because he happens to be a black man with a Muslim-sounding name.
* Members of Peace Action Milwaukee being barred from flying to a demonstration against the School of the Americas because some of their names pop up on the mysterious law-enforcement "watch list."
There's also the story of Renee Jensen in West Virginia who put a sign up in her yard reading "Mr. Bush: You're fired". This prompted a visit by the Secret Service. Or take Marc Schultz who was reported to the FBI because he stood in a line at a coffee shop reading an article critical of Fox News.
It's hardly surprising that people trying to exercise their right of free speech at, say, a Bush rally are arrested. But what is surprising to me and even more profoundly disturbing are stories like Mr. Schultz's. It's one thing for a guy donning a black trench coat and sunglasses to bully people with slogans on t-shirts – those in power like to bully those who are not. But it's absolutely chilling to read about someone being reported to the authorities by a member of their community. What must be going through your mind to call the police or the FBI when you see someone in line for a latte reading criticism of Fox News? Who did this? How did this person feel threatened?
When John Nichols of The Cap Times editorialized in favor of the book, it elicited comments which basically said that, because Rothschild was allowed to publish the book and not get sent to Gitmo, then there's no problem. Either the most extreme bad thing happens or all is well with no middle ground, no shades of gray pointing in one direction or the other. How does one acquire this mindset?
Just as Bill Lueders published his account of being on-air with Ann Althouse, I was finishing up listening to the audiobook of John Dean's Concervatives Without Conscience. In it, Dean examines the history of conservatism in this country and contrasts his Goldwater conservatism with the flavor(s) now prevailing here. He uses the research of Bob Altemeyer, specifically his research into right-wing authoritarianism. Both the negative comments directed at Nichols and Althouse's incredulity that someone would actually want to wait for evidence seemed to me authoritarian in nature – both submission and aggression. Likewise for some of the examples in Rothschild's book. 9/11 induced fear into people and the Bush administration stepped up as a father figure, of sorts, to allay those fears. Authoritarian types will tend to go along with whatever the Bush administration says because it is attempting to do away with certain fears. And they heap derision on those who would be critical of the father figure.
I am certainly not giving Dean nor Altemeyer their due and I highly recommend reading their works. It is difficult for me to read the incidents in You Have No Rights and not think that authoritarian figures are at work.
08 August, 2007
Off to the Orchard
Last weekend I sang "Cup of Wonder" by Jethro Tull to myself several times. I grilled some most excellent corn that The Dulcinea had bought and the song contains the line "lie in August's welcome corn". I really must get one of those corn de-cobbers as I'd like to try my hand at canning the stuff. Thinking about corn being in season reminded me that apples too are beginning to tempt us to pick them. I am looking forward to heading out to one (or more) of the many apple orchards around Madison. I've got a number of medieval recipes that I'd like to try that involve apples including: apple muse, a pie of grene apples, Blaunderellys (baked apples), apple cream, Fruays, Tartys in Apples, or Fretoure. Fretoure are apple fritters and you make them with ale. (Unpasteurized, please – I want that batter to rise a bit.)
The problem is that I'd love to be able to make these dishes with apples that were actually around back then. Cortlands? Developed in New York and first put on sale in 1915. McInoshes? Take off, Hoser. They're Canadian from c. 1800. Granny Smiths? These puppies originated in Australia in the mid-19th century. The University of Minnesota was busy last century developing new varieties – Zestars, Honeycrisps, Regents, Honeygolds, Haralsons, and Firesides.
This is not to say that Wisconsin is without apples to call its own. I know of two. Firstly is the Bonnie Best which originated in Cooksville, a town that is just south of Stoughton. The second is the Wolf River variety which was found c. 1880. These puppies are huge and can get up to one pound in weight. Legend has it that you can make a pie from a single Wolf River apple and I intend to test the veracity of this.
However, where I might find any medieval varieties such as the Edelborsdorfer, Costard, Pearmain, Nonpareil, or White Joaneting is beyond me at this point. The Royal Russet is an old variety which remains fairly common by which I mean not impossible to find.
While I'm on the topic of apples, the Steve's Liquor at Mineral Point and Junction Roads is having a cider tasting next Thursday the 16th from 4-6. It will feature ciders from ÆppelTreow Winery.
Oh Dionysus, Where Art Thou?
Camille Paglia has a rather distressing piece up at Salon today called "Art movies: R.I.P.". Not only does she pronounce art film dead, but also rock music and she takes some nasty & unwarranted swipes at a few prominent atheists.
Ms. Paglia's views the world through Dionysian-tinted glasses. She wants to see a world of sexual liberation and equality adorned by art whose taproot is religion, even if she rejects the tenets of its supernaturalism. It's a passion-at-all-costs philosophy where our Apollonian sides are to be chained by our natural energies, imagination, and romanticist pursuits. By way of slander she writes:
As a professed atheist, I detest the current crop of snide manifestos against religion written by professional cynics, flâneurs and imaginatively crimped and culturally challenged scientists. The narrow mental world they project is very grim indeed -- and fatal to future art…My pagan brand of atheism is predicated on worship of both nature and art. I want the great world religions taught in every school.
Just as one decodes "American Pie", I'll give this a go and suggest that here she's attacking Christopher Hitchens, Sam Harris, and Richard Dawkins specifically and, no doubt, others such as Daniel Dennett. While I can't recall if Sam Harris has espoused this, Hitchens, Dawkins, and Dennett have all said they are quite in favor of teaching the great world religions in school. Hitchens takes it upon himself to do the teaching since schools don’t do so while Dennett made his position clear at the TED Conference earlier this year and you can watch his presentation at this page. These people want religion to be studied – that's the entire argument behind Dennett's last book, in fact. They want people to know the history of the great religions; they want religion to be seen as genuine topics for inquiry and studied; they want religion to be looked at and treated as another genuine part of the human experience. What they don't want is for religion to be privileged or for kids to be indoctrinated with the notion that Yahweh actually exists whereas Zeus and Thor don't; they don't want science to be displaced by religion; they don't want the religious to impose their views upon the non-religious nor for public policy to be predicated upon a goofy, irrational belief that a fictional deity actually exists.
As far as I can tell from reading their works and interviews, none of these folks deny the profound influence of religion on art and the humanities at large. To say that Dawkins is "culturally challenged" is patently ridiculous. I don't doubt for a second that he knows next to nothing about the latest pop music acts or hit TV shows. But, if you listen to an interview which isn't just a collection of sound bites that are sure to be controversial, you will almost indubitably hear him extol his tremendous love for music and poetry. Hitchens: "I couldn't do without devotional music and architecture and poetry I must say. I've never thought it was eradicable, or that anyone should try [to eradicate it]..." I can't see what's so narrow about their mental worlds nor what is so expansive about religion. Besides, these authors do not expect their books to eradicate religion but rather see their screeds as an attempt to push religion out of the public sphere and into the private where no artist would be deprived of religious contemplation to inspire their work. And being non-religious didn't keep Percy Shelly, Mark Twain, or Ernest Hemingway from being creative. Paglia builds up a straw man and then tears him down thusly avoiding any of the arguments that the above gentlemen present.
This self-described "pagan atheist" is now 60 years old – a crone. But instead of dispensing wisdom here, she just bloviates about how things were better in her beloved Age of Aquarius in the 1960s & 70s. She goes on about seeing films by Bergman, Antonioni, and Truffaut but has all of two sentences about art film today. Seriously, all she can say about it is "But art movies are gone, gone with the wind." and "Now, in contrast, aspiring young filmmakers are stampeded toward simplistic rejection of religion based on liberal bromides (sexism, homophobia, etc.)." That's all. She never bothers to talk about any contemporary makers of art films or their films themselves. Ms. Paglia has apparently watched every art film in the whole of the world and, not having found the proper reverence for the "cosmic vision" (whatever that is) of religion in this corpus, pronounces it dead. Art films may not pack the houses like it did when Paglia was in college – after all, nudity can now be found in mainstream domestic movies – but it is still very much alive. Do you miss Antonioni? Then watch Battle in Heaven (Batalla en el cielo) by Mexican director Carlos Reygadas. Lynch, Sokurov, von Trier, and many others keep making art films. The problem is that, unless the films appeal to her sensibilities about religion as artistic inspiration, then they're worthless; unless the art film scene mirrors that of her beloved college days, it is dead.
From film she moves on to rock music which, for her, is also dead:
Rock music, which exploded in the artistic renaissance of the '60s and '70s, seems to have exhausted its formulas, At the moment, hip-hop and disco-derived dance music enjoy far greater prestige everywhere.… It's no coincidence that the geriatric Rolling Stones are still going strong: Their style is grounded in African-American rhythm and blues…"
Again we have the old fart mentality – "Everything was better in my day!" No, the reason why The Stones are "still going strong" is because Baby Boomers like you have no qualms with paying $500 for a nosebleed seat at their concerts. I say this as a Stones fan as well as someone who enjoys their latter-day albums. While not groundbreaking, Voodoo Lounge is a great album. Hip-hop and disco-derived dance music have far greater prestige everywhere? What does this mean? The much ballyhooed festivals – SXSW, Pitchfork, Lollapalooza, etc. - feature mainly rock bands. The highest grossing touring acts this year include Rod Stewart, The Police, Kenney Chesney, Roger Water, and Eric Clapton. Hip-hop album sales are declining. Some are pronouncing it dead for a myriad of reasons including that the main consumers of it are kids from the "bland white middle class" which Paglia derides later in her article. Music blogs = indie rock blogs.
Is there any hasty generalization that Ms. Paglia won't use? Rock is still very much alive and well.
Paglia trots out the tired argument that folks like Dave Marsh, Simon Frith, and Lester Bangs used as the foundation of rock criticism back in Ms. Paglia's salad days. She points to a video of Naomi Mather doing Howlin' Wolf's "Smokestack Lightning" and then declares:
In general, aspiring young performers emerging from the bland white middle class in America seem to be having trouble expressing or controlling emotion, with its myriad of subtle gradations. Unless they hail from the gospel-rich South, they lack direct experience of the vocal authority and operatic dynamics that most young African-Americans automatically absorb from church.
Marsh, et al promoted the notion that rock music had a "genuineness" to it because its taproot was folk music, most prominently, the blues (i.e. – "black music"). For them, rock becomes dislocated when it eschews its blues roots and looks towards music such as Western art music (i.e. – "white music"). For them, having blues roots allows rock musicians to adopt a process which allows feelings & emotions to be directly transcribed into music without mediation. By looking towards other sources for inspiration, this process of transcription is mediated and thusly the result is not "pure". Simply and crudely put, black music appeals to the foot while white music appeals to the head. The upshot of this way of thinking is to posit with black people a certain simplicity with rhythm being favored and white people being scorned for getting all complicated by favoring melody.
Paglia merely dresses this old argument (which is potentially girded by racism) in new clothes by shifting things to locale and, unsurprisingly, the influence of religion, which she seeks to protect and place on a pedestal. Despite the sleight of hand, her conclusions are the same – white people make "inauthentic" music while blacks make music that is "genuine". "Rock will be spectacularly reborn by a faithful return to roots," she says. Same bullshit, different clothes.
Apparently there just aren't enough rockers in tight leather pants ala Jim Morrison leading faux bacchanalias in concert halls these days for her.
Ms. Paglia's views the world through Dionysian-tinted glasses. She wants to see a world of sexual liberation and equality adorned by art whose taproot is religion, even if she rejects the tenets of its supernaturalism. It's a passion-at-all-costs philosophy where our Apollonian sides are to be chained by our natural energies, imagination, and romanticist pursuits. By way of slander she writes:
As a professed atheist, I detest the current crop of snide manifestos against religion written by professional cynics, flâneurs and imaginatively crimped and culturally challenged scientists. The narrow mental world they project is very grim indeed -- and fatal to future art…My pagan brand of atheism is predicated on worship of both nature and art. I want the great world religions taught in every school.
Just as one decodes "American Pie", I'll give this a go and suggest that here she's attacking Christopher Hitchens, Sam Harris, and Richard Dawkins specifically and, no doubt, others such as Daniel Dennett. While I can't recall if Sam Harris has espoused this, Hitchens, Dawkins, and Dennett have all said they are quite in favor of teaching the great world religions in school. Hitchens takes it upon himself to do the teaching since schools don’t do so while Dennett made his position clear at the TED Conference earlier this year and you can watch his presentation at this page. These people want religion to be studied – that's the entire argument behind Dennett's last book, in fact. They want people to know the history of the great religions; they want religion to be seen as genuine topics for inquiry and studied; they want religion to be looked at and treated as another genuine part of the human experience. What they don't want is for religion to be privileged or for kids to be indoctrinated with the notion that Yahweh actually exists whereas Zeus and Thor don't; they don't want science to be displaced by religion; they don't want the religious to impose their views upon the non-religious nor for public policy to be predicated upon a goofy, irrational belief that a fictional deity actually exists.
As far as I can tell from reading their works and interviews, none of these folks deny the profound influence of religion on art and the humanities at large. To say that Dawkins is "culturally challenged" is patently ridiculous. I don't doubt for a second that he knows next to nothing about the latest pop music acts or hit TV shows. But, if you listen to an interview which isn't just a collection of sound bites that are sure to be controversial, you will almost indubitably hear him extol his tremendous love for music and poetry. Hitchens: "I couldn't do without devotional music and architecture and poetry I must say. I've never thought it was eradicable, or that anyone should try [to eradicate it]..." I can't see what's so narrow about their mental worlds nor what is so expansive about religion. Besides, these authors do not expect their books to eradicate religion but rather see their screeds as an attempt to push religion out of the public sphere and into the private where no artist would be deprived of religious contemplation to inspire their work. And being non-religious didn't keep Percy Shelly, Mark Twain, or Ernest Hemingway from being creative. Paglia builds up a straw man and then tears him down thusly avoiding any of the arguments that the above gentlemen present.
This self-described "pagan atheist" is now 60 years old – a crone. But instead of dispensing wisdom here, she just bloviates about how things were better in her beloved Age of Aquarius in the 1960s & 70s. She goes on about seeing films by Bergman, Antonioni, and Truffaut but has all of two sentences about art film today. Seriously, all she can say about it is "But art movies are gone, gone with the wind." and "Now, in contrast, aspiring young filmmakers are stampeded toward simplistic rejection of religion based on liberal bromides (sexism, homophobia, etc.)." That's all. She never bothers to talk about any contemporary makers of art films or their films themselves. Ms. Paglia has apparently watched every art film in the whole of the world and, not having found the proper reverence for the "cosmic vision" (whatever that is) of religion in this corpus, pronounces it dead. Art films may not pack the houses like it did when Paglia was in college – after all, nudity can now be found in mainstream domestic movies – but it is still very much alive. Do you miss Antonioni? Then watch Battle in Heaven (Batalla en el cielo) by Mexican director Carlos Reygadas. Lynch, Sokurov, von Trier, and many others keep making art films. The problem is that, unless the films appeal to her sensibilities about religion as artistic inspiration, then they're worthless; unless the art film scene mirrors that of her beloved college days, it is dead.
From film she moves on to rock music which, for her, is also dead:
Rock music, which exploded in the artistic renaissance of the '60s and '70s, seems to have exhausted its formulas, At the moment, hip-hop and disco-derived dance music enjoy far greater prestige everywhere.… It's no coincidence that the geriatric Rolling Stones are still going strong: Their style is grounded in African-American rhythm and blues…"
Again we have the old fart mentality – "Everything was better in my day!" No, the reason why The Stones are "still going strong" is because Baby Boomers like you have no qualms with paying $500 for a nosebleed seat at their concerts. I say this as a Stones fan as well as someone who enjoys their latter-day albums. While not groundbreaking, Voodoo Lounge is a great album. Hip-hop and disco-derived dance music have far greater prestige everywhere? What does this mean? The much ballyhooed festivals – SXSW, Pitchfork, Lollapalooza, etc. - feature mainly rock bands. The highest grossing touring acts this year include Rod Stewart, The Police, Kenney Chesney, Roger Water, and Eric Clapton. Hip-hop album sales are declining. Some are pronouncing it dead for a myriad of reasons including that the main consumers of it are kids from the "bland white middle class" which Paglia derides later in her article. Music blogs = indie rock blogs.
Is there any hasty generalization that Ms. Paglia won't use? Rock is still very much alive and well.
Paglia trots out the tired argument that folks like Dave Marsh, Simon Frith, and Lester Bangs used as the foundation of rock criticism back in Ms. Paglia's salad days. She points to a video of Naomi Mather doing Howlin' Wolf's "Smokestack Lightning" and then declares:
In general, aspiring young performers emerging from the bland white middle class in America seem to be having trouble expressing or controlling emotion, with its myriad of subtle gradations. Unless they hail from the gospel-rich South, they lack direct experience of the vocal authority and operatic dynamics that most young African-Americans automatically absorb from church.
Marsh, et al promoted the notion that rock music had a "genuineness" to it because its taproot was folk music, most prominently, the blues (i.e. – "black music"). For them, rock becomes dislocated when it eschews its blues roots and looks towards music such as Western art music (i.e. – "white music"). For them, having blues roots allows rock musicians to adopt a process which allows feelings & emotions to be directly transcribed into music without mediation. By looking towards other sources for inspiration, this process of transcription is mediated and thusly the result is not "pure". Simply and crudely put, black music appeals to the foot while white music appeals to the head. The upshot of this way of thinking is to posit with black people a certain simplicity with rhythm being favored and white people being scorned for getting all complicated by favoring melody.
Paglia merely dresses this old argument (which is potentially girded by racism) in new clothes by shifting things to locale and, unsurprisingly, the influence of religion, which she seeks to protect and place on a pedestal. Despite the sleight of hand, her conclusions are the same – white people make "inauthentic" music while blacks make music that is "genuine". "Rock will be spectacularly reborn by a faithful return to roots," she says. Same bullshit, different clothes.
Apparently there just aren't enough rockers in tight leather pants ala Jim Morrison leading faux bacchanalias in concert halls these days for her.
Davros to Return?
The UK tabloid The Sun is reporting that Dalek creator Davros is to return in the next season of Doctor who and that a big name has been tapped to play the part:
Doctor Who bosses are set to sign up Gandhi star Sir Ben Kingsley to play the Daleks' creator Davros.
Sir Ben, 63 - who won an Oscar for his movie role as India's peace-loving spiritual leader - is in final negotiations to play one of the most dangerous baddies in the galaxy.
A source said: "Ben's agent has been in talks for a while now and he's very keen to play the part of Davros. A deal will be signed any day now."
Fans will be delighted that insane half-man, half-machine Davros is returning for the fourth series of the hit BBC1 show, which stars David Tennant as the Timelord.
The alien scientist - who first battled the Doctor in 1975 - is hell-bent on destruction with his army of exterminating Daleks.
Doctor Who bosses are set to sign up Gandhi star Sir Ben Kingsley to play the Daleks' creator Davros.
Sir Ben, 63 - who won an Oscar for his movie role as India's peace-loving spiritual leader - is in final negotiations to play one of the most dangerous baddies in the galaxy.
A source said: "Ben's agent has been in talks for a while now and he's very keen to play the part of Davros. A deal will be signed any day now."
Fans will be delighted that insane half-man, half-machine Davros is returning for the fourth series of the hit BBC1 show, which stars David Tennant as the Timelord.
The alien scientist - who first battled the Doctor in 1975 - is hell-bent on destruction with his army of exterminating Daleks.
07 August, 2007
Disaster Averted on German Train
It could have been a disaster when a tap broke aboard a train loaded with German soccer/football fans. Luckily quick action saved the day.
Federal police said Monday that the beer tap failed aboard a special train carrying Bayer Leverkusen fans to Hamburg on Saturday. The fault was discovered half an hour into the journey.
"In order not to endanger the good mood" of the passengers, railway officials halted the train in Wuppertal for 25 minutes and had a replacement part delivered by taxi, a police statement said. It added that there was no trouble among the fans.
Federal police said Monday that the beer tap failed aboard a special train carrying Bayer Leverkusen fans to Hamburg on Saturday. The fault was discovered half an hour into the journey.
"In order not to endanger the good mood" of the passengers, railway officials halted the train in Wuppertal for 25 minutes and had a replacement part delivered by taxi, a police statement said. It added that there was no trouble among the fans.
There Really Are Atheists in Foxholes and They Still Get Berated by Christians
This comes courtesy of Ed Brayton. It's the text of an e-mail he received concerning a very small gathering of U.S. soldiers in Iraq who are atheists. The message was originally sent to Kathleen Johnson, the military director for American Atheists.
Kathleen Johnson:
Thought you'd be interested in this report of the first-ever meeting of Atheist service-members in Iraq under the umbrella of the MAAF-Iraq chapter of the Military Association of Atheists and Freethinkers. This meeting was put together by the same young MAAF member who recently had his second letter published in the Stars and Stripes.
One of our members, a young Atheist enlisted soldier, thought he would like to see if he could generate some interest in MAAF meetings at his Forward Operating Base (FOB) here in Iraq (not the base I'm at, by the way). He got things coordinated and started hanging flyers, and after weeks of having to re-hang his flyers almost daily because some vandal kept tearing them down, he finally succeeded in having a small MAAF meeting. I wasn't there because the meeting wasn't on my FOB, but I knew he was holding it and was expecting to hear from him after the meeting. Keep in mind that this young soldier did everything right - he went through the Chaplain's office and jumped through all the hoops it takes to legally hold meetings that are religiously or philosophically based. Four soldiers attended this meeting - all of them very junior enlisted soldiers with the exception of one Major (an O-4), who claimed to be a "freethinker".
Well, to make a very long story a little shorter, the Major turned out to be a fundamentalist Christian who verbally berated the other attendees, accused them of plotting against Christians and disrespecting soldiers who have died protecting the Constitution, and threatened them with punishment under the UCMJ for their activities (said they were "going down") and said he would do whatever it took to shut the meetings down. Keep in mind that by this point, he had two of the attendees (one soldier fled when the shouting started) standing at the position of attention so that he could yell at them, berate them, and humiliate them. This apparently went on for several minutes at which time the Major shut down the meeting by saying he wasn't some "push-over Chaplain" and that he would not tolerate the meetings to continue.
The young MAAF member who hosted the meeting is absolutely freaked out about what happened, but he said he's going to continue with the meetings and isn't going to be bullied by the prayer warriors. I've advised him to immediately notify the Chaplain sponsor of what happened to get guidance while I try to figure out what to do next. I should hear something back from him tonight sometime and there's even a small possibility I might be able to score a mission to his FOB and attend one of his meetings in the next few weeks (if I do, I'll meet with the Chaplain in person).
As for immediate action, he's going to get me the names of his Chaplain sponsor and the name of the officer who disrupted the meeting. My intent right now is to make a formal report to the most senior Chaplain I can find along with possibly an Equal Opportunity complaint against the officer if we can get him fully identified. I may not be eligible to make that complaint because I wasn't there, but I can at least smooth the way for this young troop to make one if he elects to. At the very least, I can make the EO office formally aware of what happened there.
More info will follow when I get it, but right now, feel free to disseminate this information since I've intentionally sanitized it for names and locations. I will be happy to forward any words of support to him if they get mailed to my (redacted email) address - he could really use some encouragement right now, I think.
Is there any level to which Fundies won't stoop? Here these guys are thousands of miles from home serving their country and they still get hassled by Christians.
Kathleen Johnson:
Thought you'd be interested in this report of the first-ever meeting of Atheist service-members in Iraq under the umbrella of the MAAF-Iraq chapter of the Military Association of Atheists and Freethinkers. This meeting was put together by the same young MAAF member who recently had his second letter published in the Stars and Stripes.
One of our members, a young Atheist enlisted soldier, thought he would like to see if he could generate some interest in MAAF meetings at his Forward Operating Base (FOB) here in Iraq (not the base I'm at, by the way). He got things coordinated and started hanging flyers, and after weeks of having to re-hang his flyers almost daily because some vandal kept tearing them down, he finally succeeded in having a small MAAF meeting. I wasn't there because the meeting wasn't on my FOB, but I knew he was holding it and was expecting to hear from him after the meeting. Keep in mind that this young soldier did everything right - he went through the Chaplain's office and jumped through all the hoops it takes to legally hold meetings that are religiously or philosophically based. Four soldiers attended this meeting - all of them very junior enlisted soldiers with the exception of one Major (an O-4), who claimed to be a "freethinker".
Well, to make a very long story a little shorter, the Major turned out to be a fundamentalist Christian who verbally berated the other attendees, accused them of plotting against Christians and disrespecting soldiers who have died protecting the Constitution, and threatened them with punishment under the UCMJ for their activities (said they were "going down") and said he would do whatever it took to shut the meetings down. Keep in mind that by this point, he had two of the attendees (one soldier fled when the shouting started) standing at the position of attention so that he could yell at them, berate them, and humiliate them. This apparently went on for several minutes at which time the Major shut down the meeting by saying he wasn't some "push-over Chaplain" and that he would not tolerate the meetings to continue.
The young MAAF member who hosted the meeting is absolutely freaked out about what happened, but he said he's going to continue with the meetings and isn't going to be bullied by the prayer warriors. I've advised him to immediately notify the Chaplain sponsor of what happened to get guidance while I try to figure out what to do next. I should hear something back from him tonight sometime and there's even a small possibility I might be able to score a mission to his FOB and attend one of his meetings in the next few weeks (if I do, I'll meet with the Chaplain in person).
As for immediate action, he's going to get me the names of his Chaplain sponsor and the name of the officer who disrupted the meeting. My intent right now is to make a formal report to the most senior Chaplain I can find along with possibly an Equal Opportunity complaint against the officer if we can get him fully identified. I may not be eligible to make that complaint because I wasn't there, but I can at least smooth the way for this young troop to make one if he elects to. At the very least, I can make the EO office formally aware of what happened there.
More info will follow when I get it, but right now, feel free to disseminate this information since I've intentionally sanitized it for names and locations. I will be happy to forward any words of support to him if they get mailed to my (redacted email) address - he could really use some encouragement right now, I think.
Is there any level to which Fundies won't stoop? Here these guys are thousands of miles from home serving their country and they still get hassled by Christians.
05 August, 2007
Indie Sex
(Photo found here.)
Violet Blue has a mini-review of the new IFC series that debuted this weekend - Indie Sex. Ms. Blue is an author, blogger, and sex educator. Given her sex positive pedigree, it's not surprising that found it riveting. I too have watched it and found it informative as well as entertaining but I just can't gush over it like Ms. Blue.
One thing that struck me came in the last episode when John Cameron Mitchell was discussing his film Shortbus. He described it as being about a group of sexually dysfunctional New Yorkers and it occurred to me that many of the folks interviewed were from New York. When I shifted my mind from the flesh on my TV screen and looked at the show critically, I felt it was overly pedantic. There are times when it feels like the program bombards the viewer with the pontificating of film critics from New York. If you are a reviewer from the Village Voice or The New Yorker, then your opinions about sex and its role in life & art are privileged or sacrosanct. I agreed with most of what was said but it got old hearing the same people espousing essentially the same point of view over and over and over. I think the lone voice outside of the film community was Dita von Teese, a burlesque performer and you've got to be shittin' me if you think I'm going to accept her commentary as being typical vox populi. There were no dissenters, not even someone saying, "I think sex certainly has a role in art generally and film specifically but this particular movie was crap."
Watching a critic in his late 20s give an encomium for Porky's made me acutely aware that virtually everyone was fairly young. This guy was shitting his pants when the film came out and this brings up another criticism. With the emphasis on younger interviewees, there was an overload of comments about how this person or that saw a particular film as a youth followed by how the experience made the person feel and react. I wasn't expecting a bunch of octogenarians to give their perspectives on blue movies from the 1930s but how hard could it have been to find folks who were mature adults in the 1980s to talk about the teen sex flick? How difficult could it have been to find an older person who could give a first hand account of watching the portrayals of sex and sexuality in films change from, say, the 1950s up to the present? I felt like yelling at the television, "There are still people alive from back then, you know. You don't have to have someone born in the mid-1960s up there talking about the period as if it were ancient history!"
While the series is to be applauded for taking a serious look at topics that don't get a lot of attention and some of which are taboo, it is easy to watch and think of it as white people talking about white people who make movies about beautiful white people having sex. For all the lip service paid to the notion that indie films portray sex and sexuality in ways that are more realistic and more like the experiences of real folks in the audiences at theatres, there were sure a ton of groups of real people excluded. The only instance where there was an abundance of people of color came during the "Teens" episode in which one film about black teenage girls was discussed - Just Another Girl on the I.R.T.. That's it, as far as I can recall. And the films discussed to the exclusion of one featured thin people who conformed to the popular notions of beauty. The only instance of someone who is overweight being featured was again in the "Teens" episode with the French film À ma soeur! (Fat Girl). Have films never addressed the sexuality of an overweight adult? The vast majority of people in the films discussed were stereotypes of physical beauty. The women were thin as were the men and, at least in newer films, the gents were all perfectly fit and hairless.
I can see why Violet Blue was riveted by the series and can understand that she saw a portrayal of sex & sexuality in the films featured in which she can see her experiences reflected. After all, she is young, white, thin, and conventionally pretty. The Indie Sex series broached an interesting and important topic – of that there's no doubt. But it was unable to justify its claim that indie films give a reflection of the sexual experiences and sexuality of the average Janes and Joes who populate theatre audiences. The program was too white, too pretty, and relied too much on the opinions of younger, cosmopolitan New Yorkers.
Towards a YouTube Aesthetic?
UW professor and independent filmmaker J.J. Murphy recently posted some commentary at his blog about the viability of YouTube as a distribution vehicle. Although I have some ideas for documentaries that I'd love to do, I am no filmmaker so I just wanted to post some thoughts from the P.O.V. of a viewer, of a consumer.
Murphy's post centers around the film Four Eyed Monsters. The film's financial prospects looked dim going the festival route so the creators have posted the film on YouTube and, in general, use the Web as the primary promotional vehicle.
Murphy's complaints are that YouTube generates no direct income and that time spent trying to promote the film via various social networking sites is time not spent being creative on another project. I'll have to let the art v. commerce issue be one that the filmmakers deal with since I'm merely a consumer. However, reading Murphy's comments made me question just who would want to sit in front of a computer screen and watch a feature film in a small box and of mediocre video & audio quality. The Dulcinea recently bought a video iPod and I put some episodes of LOST on it for her both because she hasn't seen any of last season and as an experiment, of sorts. Watching it to make sure my work had paid off, I was struck by how uninspiring and unsatisfactory it is to watch the program on such a small screen. Perhaps this is because I'm spoiled as I was able to watch most of last season in high definition on a 52" TV. Still, I must wonder if we're so desperate to watch moving pictures that we will accept even the smallest screen sizes and the lowest acceptable quality. If I had an hour-long commute each morning sitting on a train or bus, watching an iPod might be fun but I don't and I can't see myself sitting in a coffee shop staring at such a tiny screen.
Murphy says, "My point is simply that people are not going to attend screenings, rent films, or buy DVDs when the work is already available for free on YouTube." I would hazard a guess and say that this certainly applies to many people, though not all. All quibbling over numbers aside, the comment also illustrates the double-edged nature of the Net and things like iPods. The Internet surely delivers quantity but is quality being sacrificed? Would the majority of people rather watch a movie on YouTube for free than pay to see it in a theatre or watch it on DVD?
I know a couple people who, like me, are fans of Doctor Who and who download the show rather than wait a few months for it to be shown on PBS or the Sci-Fi Channel. The two people I'm thinking of immediately download the most recent episode when it's available which means they download files that are 350-375MB. On the other hand, I wait a few more hours to begin the much lengthier process of downloading the episode as a 1.5GB file. Does this make me a snob and/or old fashioned? Sometimes I wonder if music is being cheapened. I mean, if your audience is increasingly going to buy a single song instead of an album and in a lossy compression format where certain frequencies (usually on the high end) are lost and then listen to it with earbuds that can't reproduce much bass, are you as a musician going to stop caring about making a quality recordings because no one will notice anyway?
Professor Murphy's concern in his post is compensation. For me, I have to wonder, if you're a filmmaker and you know a major venue for your work will be a tiny portion of a computer screen or some kind of portable media player, how, if at all, will that influence how you make your films?
Here is Four Eyed Monsters:
Murphy's post centers around the film Four Eyed Monsters. The film's financial prospects looked dim going the festival route so the creators have posted the film on YouTube and, in general, use the Web as the primary promotional vehicle.
Murphy's complaints are that YouTube generates no direct income and that time spent trying to promote the film via various social networking sites is time not spent being creative on another project. I'll have to let the art v. commerce issue be one that the filmmakers deal with since I'm merely a consumer. However, reading Murphy's comments made me question just who would want to sit in front of a computer screen and watch a feature film in a small box and of mediocre video & audio quality. The Dulcinea recently bought a video iPod and I put some episodes of LOST on it for her both because she hasn't seen any of last season and as an experiment, of sorts. Watching it to make sure my work had paid off, I was struck by how uninspiring and unsatisfactory it is to watch the program on such a small screen. Perhaps this is because I'm spoiled as I was able to watch most of last season in high definition on a 52" TV. Still, I must wonder if we're so desperate to watch moving pictures that we will accept even the smallest screen sizes and the lowest acceptable quality. If I had an hour-long commute each morning sitting on a train or bus, watching an iPod might be fun but I don't and I can't see myself sitting in a coffee shop staring at such a tiny screen.
Murphy says, "My point is simply that people are not going to attend screenings, rent films, or buy DVDs when the work is already available for free on YouTube." I would hazard a guess and say that this certainly applies to many people, though not all. All quibbling over numbers aside, the comment also illustrates the double-edged nature of the Net and things like iPods. The Internet surely delivers quantity but is quality being sacrificed? Would the majority of people rather watch a movie on YouTube for free than pay to see it in a theatre or watch it on DVD?
I know a couple people who, like me, are fans of Doctor Who and who download the show rather than wait a few months for it to be shown on PBS or the Sci-Fi Channel. The two people I'm thinking of immediately download the most recent episode when it's available which means they download files that are 350-375MB. On the other hand, I wait a few more hours to begin the much lengthier process of downloading the episode as a 1.5GB file. Does this make me a snob and/or old fashioned? Sometimes I wonder if music is being cheapened. I mean, if your audience is increasingly going to buy a single song instead of an album and in a lossy compression format where certain frequencies (usually on the high end) are lost and then listen to it with earbuds that can't reproduce much bass, are you as a musician going to stop caring about making a quality recordings because no one will notice anyway?
Professor Murphy's concern in his post is compensation. For me, I have to wonder, if you're a filmmaker and you know a major venue for your work will be a tiny portion of a computer screen or some kind of portable media player, how, if at all, will that influence how you make your films?
Here is Four Eyed Monsters:
03 August, 2007
At the Sinny – Setting the Controls for the Heart of the Sun
I have a bad habit of reading too much about films before I go and see them. Sometimes this doesn't matter an awful lot if the movie is a remake or based on source material with which I am familiar. But other times is drains the surprise away because I either know what's going to happen or have gleaned enough info to make educated guesses. In the case of the film I saw last night - Sunshine - I had read only the slimmest of summaries before heading to the theatre. The reviewer had said that the first half was in the vein of 2001: A Space Odyssey while the second deteriorated into schlock. But even this barest preview setup expectations and preconceptions in my mind and I'm still ambivalent about whether the film is in some way objectively messy or that it merely didn’t meet my expectations.
The year is 2057 and our distant sister Sun is dying. The small crew of Icarus II are nearing Mercury as they hurdle towards the sun to deliver a nuclear payload which will "re-ignite" the star and thusly save mankind. This second incarnation of the mission was brought about because the first neared the Sun and was then never heard from again. The ship itself is a long needlelike vessel with antennae rotating along its axis and a massive heat shield out front that protects the ship as it approaches the Sun. The shots of Icarus II from outside the ship are truly awe-inspiring; from the short fly-by cutaways to the extended scenes, the Sun looms ominously in the background. Director Danny Boyle and his DP Alwin Küchler took great advantage of the 2.35:1 aspect ratio. Not only are the exterior shots gorgeously panoramic, but many interior shots place characters (and sometimes just their faces) at the extreme ends of the frame. This is a film not to be missed on the big screen.
Towards the beginning of the film, we witness the crew sharing a meal. There is some light-hearted banter but tension as well with one crewmember taking complaints about the dinner directly to the cook who becomes irritated. They eat at a table whose surface is lit and anyone who has seen Alien will find him- or herself feeling déjà vu. Lighting from below casts the crew's faces in a pallid miasma which mirrors their states of mind. Having been aboard the ship for years with just one another for company and the fate of humanity in their hands, they are drained of any exuberance and are just ready to complete the mission. Their faces stand in stark contrast to the photo of the crew that hangs on one of the walls. Presumably taken shortly after lift-off, it features brilliant colors and a host of smiles.
Hiroyuki Sanada plays Captain Kaneda. With his straight hair and scruffy beard, I again thought of Alien as he looked suspiciously like Tom Skerritt's Dallas. The ship's botanist is Coraxon as played by Michelle Yeoh of Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon fame. She tends to the ship's greenhouse which provides food and oxygen. Cillian Murphy is Capa, a young physicist on whose shoulder the burden of detonating the payload falls. The crew is rounded out by Harvey, Cassie, Mace, Trey, and Searle who is the ship's psychologist and responsible for the crew's mental health. This is the same man who grasps at fleeting moments of transcendence in the observation deck by staring at the Sun through windows tinted just enough to keep him from going instantly blind. ("It's invigorating, like taking a shower in light.")

Icarus II approaches Mercury as the plan is to use the gravity of the planet to slingshot it further on towards its destination. (A trick used in 2010.) As it approaches, a signal is detected which is identified as the distress call from Icarus I. Searle suggests that their course be altered so as to make contact with the stranded vessel to find out if its payload remains intact. The reasoning being that two massive nuclear matches are better than one. This deviation brings out high emotions amongst the crew but the clam, pensive Kenada defers the decision to Capa as he is the physicist. Capa eventually comes to agree with Searle and a rendezvous is plotted.
He and Cassie are having what is perhaps the closest thing to a tender moment when Icarus II violently shudders. Trey had made the modifications for the rendezvous but he had neglected to alter the angle of the heat shield. This prompts an extravehicular walk by Kaneda and Capa to examine the shield. I absolutely adored the spacesuits. They were these huge, bulky things with a welder's mask attached and were a million miles away from anything sleek. As they are out repairing the broken panels of the shield, the ship's computer does a HAL and refuses to let the crew maneuver the ship so that Kaneda and Capa are out of the Sun's fiery gaze. Kaneda sacrifices himself although the physicist survives. As the captain is enveloped by giant furnace before him, Searle asks him to describe what it's like.
This brings me to something that disappointed me about the film. By this time, Searle has spent so much time in the observation room that the skin on his face is peeling off. This certainly makes for a disturbed yet very interesting character. While I greatly appreciated that he didn't lose his mind and collapse into a psycho killer (which is very much against type) but Searle is never developed. The scene with him in the observation room has many close-ups of his eyes behind a pair of sunglasses and, indeed, such close-ups are very prominent throughout the first third or so of the film. I distinctly recall sitting there after 20 minutes thinking that Sunshine used the eye motif the most of any film since Blade Runner. Unfortunately this motif suddenly disappears and is only briefly resurrected towards the end. It felt like every motif and theme got up but never went anywhere. Such thematic dead ends would have been fine if the film had an existentialist bent like Le Samouraï but Sunshine never developed a cohesive stratagem in the department. In addition, the dialogue and plot never much doubt as to the fate of the crew so this stylistic device seemed overkill. Is this a "mistake" by the filmmakers or my expectations having been thwarted?
Icarus II eventually meets the rendezvous point. Trey is so wracked with guilt that he is sedated lest he commit suicide and four of the remaining crew members board Icarus I. As the crew enter via the airlock, quick flashes of Icarus I's crew appear. These are from their own colorful portrait and these brief glimpses are disorientating but not distracting making them quite effective. The interior is covered in a layer of dust but the greenhouse has flourished and is overgrown. A message from the captain of the dead ship, Pinbacker, is found and played. The video is pixilated and distorted and the voice on the message is clearly one of someone who's gone insane. He speaks of talking to God and other such delusions. Eventually the crew are found in the observation deck having been turned to dust by a blast of the sun's rays at full exposure. The core of the ship's computers, which need to be submerged in coolant, are discovered to have raised out of the liquid - they overheated and shut down. As Mace wanders in the lush greenhouse, Icarus I shudders. The connection of the two ships' airlocks has been sabotaged. Searle sacrifices himself by manually operating the airlock door to allow Capa, Mace, and Harvey to get blasted out towards Icarus II. Harvey misses the target and flies off where he freezes to death while Capa and Mace make it back into the airlock.
Aboard Icarus II, it has been calculated that there was enough oxygen to get four of them home and, in an all-too brief scene, it is decided that Trey must be killed. Mace goes to the medical room only to find Trey slouched against the wall in a pool of blood let from his wrists. Meanwhile Capa is checking the payload and making sure it will be ready for detonation. He asks the computer about the crew and discovers that there is a fifth person aboard who is on the observation deck. Capa investigates and finds that it is Captain Pinbacker whose body has been severely burned and he looks like a walking scar. This scene was shot as a near white-out with the figures barely penetrating the glare. When we do see Pinbacker, the image becomes distorted which questions Pinbacker's physical make-up or Capa's sanity.
At this point the film turns into a thriller as a creature ranting and raving about sending humanity to heaven hunts down the crew. I'm ambivalent about it. On one hand, it is just formulaic. But on the other it is symbolic with a war between religion and science, destiny and determinism being played out. While I appreciate the symbolism, it is inserted too late in the game to have much of an impact. As I noted above, thematic material has an incredibly short half-life in this film. If the crew had talked about it and it had been developed from the start, this conflict would have had stronger resonance.
Just as Sunshine hints at other classic sci-fi films such as 2001, Alien, and Solaris, it only dips its toe into the metaphysical pool. The characters are occupied by their concerns over the vagaries of space flight and their technology which means precious little time is given to scenes where Icarus II is humming along smoothly. To make matters worse, most of these scenes merely serve as brief preludes to trouble befalling the ship and crew.
Those who see this film on the small screen are lost but I'm still looking forward to the DVD release as I’m hoping for extended and deleted scenes. Sunshine clocks in at under two hours and, to my mind, it could have benefited from another 30 minutes of running time. I am forced to wonder if more scenes like those of Searle on the observation deck and Kenada in his quarters watching a video message were left on the cutting room floor. And perhaps there are more of the crew interacting in a way that involves socializing and/or moments of reflection instead of troubleshooting. My problems with Sunshine are more about what it's not rather than what it is. I didn't need grand themes popping up all over the place but I kept waiting for the less grandiose thematic devices to point me somewhere instead of just trailing off. While the cul-de-sacs could have been meaningful in and of themselves, I didn’t feel the movie did much to imbue them with importance.

Despite these criticisms, the film did many things right. The best was the all-pervasive mood which I can only describe as giving a sense of stately loneliness. It does this via a combination of great sets, cinematography, and by juxtaposing the interior of Icarus II against what is happening outside it. Inside the ship is a cramped, almost lifeless, world of drab grays that is betrayed only by the occasional glimpse of the verdant greenhouse and Trey's crimson blood. It is a mechanical environment where everything is done with mathematical precision. Meanwhile, outside is an exemplary hierarchy of size with the goliath heat shield which is dwarfed by the enormity of the Sun which, in turn, pales in comparison the vastness of space. The brilliance of the refulgent orb contrasts with the blackness of the great emptiness and exterior scenes are full of bright areas and those black or shaded. Unlike the interior of Icarus II, the Sun is active and appears alive with its tentacles of flame swirling and eddying as they seem to reach out at the ship. The great widescreen cinematography is complemented well by the music which is by the electronic group Underworld. The score is very minimal and highly moody. There were a few scenes where I wished that music was absent but, on the whole, its drones and rumbles served the visuals well.
As I noted earlier, Sunshine is a fantastic widescreen spectacle from the vast stretches of space to the arguments between crew members which pitted the verbal pugilists at opposite ends of the screen. The scene where Capa finds the mutated Pinbacker in the observation room almost made me shield my eyes and there were a couple other instances where the brilliance overwhelms the screen which fades to white. The first act features very shallow depth of field with close-ups of people's faces and extreme close-ups of their eyes. It helped establish the cramped feel inside Icarus II and did a bit to humanize the characters who were trapped in a technological bubble left to single-mindedly carry out a task. Plus it made the exterior shots all the more expansive. When this shooting style returns very late in the film, it helps bring things full circle as we see Cassie shed tears, Corazon's joy at finding that one seedling had survived a fire, and Pinbacker's madness.
Although Sunshine is scattered thematically, it is a bracing film visually and viscerally. It creates a mood and a tension which creeps inside and stays with you. I noticed things around me in the theatre maybe two times – it held my attention that well. If I have seemed overly harsh on the film this is because I enjoyed it tremendously and just wished that there was a little more to get it over the hump so it could take its place with the greats of the genre.
The year is 2057 and our distant sister Sun is dying. The small crew of Icarus II are nearing Mercury as they hurdle towards the sun to deliver a nuclear payload which will "re-ignite" the star and thusly save mankind. This second incarnation of the mission was brought about because the first neared the Sun and was then never heard from again. The ship itself is a long needlelike vessel with antennae rotating along its axis and a massive heat shield out front that protects the ship as it approaches the Sun. The shots of Icarus II from outside the ship are truly awe-inspiring; from the short fly-by cutaways to the extended scenes, the Sun looms ominously in the background. Director Danny Boyle and his DP Alwin Küchler took great advantage of the 2.35:1 aspect ratio. Not only are the exterior shots gorgeously panoramic, but many interior shots place characters (and sometimes just their faces) at the extreme ends of the frame. This is a film not to be missed on the big screen.
Towards the beginning of the film, we witness the crew sharing a meal. There is some light-hearted banter but tension as well with one crewmember taking complaints about the dinner directly to the cook who becomes irritated. They eat at a table whose surface is lit and anyone who has seen Alien will find him- or herself feeling déjà vu. Lighting from below casts the crew's faces in a pallid miasma which mirrors their states of mind. Having been aboard the ship for years with just one another for company and the fate of humanity in their hands, they are drained of any exuberance and are just ready to complete the mission. Their faces stand in stark contrast to the photo of the crew that hangs on one of the walls. Presumably taken shortly after lift-off, it features brilliant colors and a host of smiles.
Hiroyuki Sanada plays Captain Kaneda. With his straight hair and scruffy beard, I again thought of Alien as he looked suspiciously like Tom Skerritt's Dallas. The ship's botanist is Coraxon as played by Michelle Yeoh of Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon fame. She tends to the ship's greenhouse which provides food and oxygen. Cillian Murphy is Capa, a young physicist on whose shoulder the burden of detonating the payload falls. The crew is rounded out by Harvey, Cassie, Mace, Trey, and Searle who is the ship's psychologist and responsible for the crew's mental health. This is the same man who grasps at fleeting moments of transcendence in the observation deck by staring at the Sun through windows tinted just enough to keep him from going instantly blind. ("It's invigorating, like taking a shower in light.")
Icarus II approaches Mercury as the plan is to use the gravity of the planet to slingshot it further on towards its destination. (A trick used in 2010.) As it approaches, a signal is detected which is identified as the distress call from Icarus I. Searle suggests that their course be altered so as to make contact with the stranded vessel to find out if its payload remains intact. The reasoning being that two massive nuclear matches are better than one. This deviation brings out high emotions amongst the crew but the clam, pensive Kenada defers the decision to Capa as he is the physicist. Capa eventually comes to agree with Searle and a rendezvous is plotted.
He and Cassie are having what is perhaps the closest thing to a tender moment when Icarus II violently shudders. Trey had made the modifications for the rendezvous but he had neglected to alter the angle of the heat shield. This prompts an extravehicular walk by Kaneda and Capa to examine the shield. I absolutely adored the spacesuits. They were these huge, bulky things with a welder's mask attached and were a million miles away from anything sleek. As they are out repairing the broken panels of the shield, the ship's computer does a HAL and refuses to let the crew maneuver the ship so that Kaneda and Capa are out of the Sun's fiery gaze. Kaneda sacrifices himself although the physicist survives. As the captain is enveloped by giant furnace before him, Searle asks him to describe what it's like.
This brings me to something that disappointed me about the film. By this time, Searle has spent so much time in the observation room that the skin on his face is peeling off. This certainly makes for a disturbed yet very interesting character. While I greatly appreciated that he didn't lose his mind and collapse into a psycho killer (which is very much against type) but Searle is never developed. The scene with him in the observation room has many close-ups of his eyes behind a pair of sunglasses and, indeed, such close-ups are very prominent throughout the first third or so of the film. I distinctly recall sitting there after 20 minutes thinking that Sunshine used the eye motif the most of any film since Blade Runner. Unfortunately this motif suddenly disappears and is only briefly resurrected towards the end. It felt like every motif and theme got up but never went anywhere. Such thematic dead ends would have been fine if the film had an existentialist bent like Le Samouraï but Sunshine never developed a cohesive stratagem in the department. In addition, the dialogue and plot never much doubt as to the fate of the crew so this stylistic device seemed overkill. Is this a "mistake" by the filmmakers or my expectations having been thwarted?
Icarus II eventually meets the rendezvous point. Trey is so wracked with guilt that he is sedated lest he commit suicide and four of the remaining crew members board Icarus I. As the crew enter via the airlock, quick flashes of Icarus I's crew appear. These are from their own colorful portrait and these brief glimpses are disorientating but not distracting making them quite effective. The interior is covered in a layer of dust but the greenhouse has flourished and is overgrown. A message from the captain of the dead ship, Pinbacker, is found and played. The video is pixilated and distorted and the voice on the message is clearly one of someone who's gone insane. He speaks of talking to God and other such delusions. Eventually the crew are found in the observation deck having been turned to dust by a blast of the sun's rays at full exposure. The core of the ship's computers, which need to be submerged in coolant, are discovered to have raised out of the liquid - they overheated and shut down. As Mace wanders in the lush greenhouse, Icarus I shudders. The connection of the two ships' airlocks has been sabotaged. Searle sacrifices himself by manually operating the airlock door to allow Capa, Mace, and Harvey to get blasted out towards Icarus II. Harvey misses the target and flies off where he freezes to death while Capa and Mace make it back into the airlock.
Aboard Icarus II, it has been calculated that there was enough oxygen to get four of them home and, in an all-too brief scene, it is decided that Trey must be killed. Mace goes to the medical room only to find Trey slouched against the wall in a pool of blood let from his wrists. Meanwhile Capa is checking the payload and making sure it will be ready for detonation. He asks the computer about the crew and discovers that there is a fifth person aboard who is on the observation deck. Capa investigates and finds that it is Captain Pinbacker whose body has been severely burned and he looks like a walking scar. This scene was shot as a near white-out with the figures barely penetrating the glare. When we do see Pinbacker, the image becomes distorted which questions Pinbacker's physical make-up or Capa's sanity.
At this point the film turns into a thriller as a creature ranting and raving about sending humanity to heaven hunts down the crew. I'm ambivalent about it. On one hand, it is just formulaic. But on the other it is symbolic with a war between religion and science, destiny and determinism being played out. While I appreciate the symbolism, it is inserted too late in the game to have much of an impact. As I noted above, thematic material has an incredibly short half-life in this film. If the crew had talked about it and it had been developed from the start, this conflict would have had stronger resonance.
Just as Sunshine hints at other classic sci-fi films such as 2001, Alien, and Solaris, it only dips its toe into the metaphysical pool. The characters are occupied by their concerns over the vagaries of space flight and their technology which means precious little time is given to scenes where Icarus II is humming along smoothly. To make matters worse, most of these scenes merely serve as brief preludes to trouble befalling the ship and crew.
Those who see this film on the small screen are lost but I'm still looking forward to the DVD release as I’m hoping for extended and deleted scenes. Sunshine clocks in at under two hours and, to my mind, it could have benefited from another 30 minutes of running time. I am forced to wonder if more scenes like those of Searle on the observation deck and Kenada in his quarters watching a video message were left on the cutting room floor. And perhaps there are more of the crew interacting in a way that involves socializing and/or moments of reflection instead of troubleshooting. My problems with Sunshine are more about what it's not rather than what it is. I didn't need grand themes popping up all over the place but I kept waiting for the less grandiose thematic devices to point me somewhere instead of just trailing off. While the cul-de-sacs could have been meaningful in and of themselves, I didn’t feel the movie did much to imbue them with importance.
Despite these criticisms, the film did many things right. The best was the all-pervasive mood which I can only describe as giving a sense of stately loneliness. It does this via a combination of great sets, cinematography, and by juxtaposing the interior of Icarus II against what is happening outside it. Inside the ship is a cramped, almost lifeless, world of drab grays that is betrayed only by the occasional glimpse of the verdant greenhouse and Trey's crimson blood. It is a mechanical environment where everything is done with mathematical precision. Meanwhile, outside is an exemplary hierarchy of size with the goliath heat shield which is dwarfed by the enormity of the Sun which, in turn, pales in comparison the vastness of space. The brilliance of the refulgent orb contrasts with the blackness of the great emptiness and exterior scenes are full of bright areas and those black or shaded. Unlike the interior of Icarus II, the Sun is active and appears alive with its tentacles of flame swirling and eddying as they seem to reach out at the ship. The great widescreen cinematography is complemented well by the music which is by the electronic group Underworld. The score is very minimal and highly moody. There were a few scenes where I wished that music was absent but, on the whole, its drones and rumbles served the visuals well.
As I noted earlier, Sunshine is a fantastic widescreen spectacle from the vast stretches of space to the arguments between crew members which pitted the verbal pugilists at opposite ends of the screen. The scene where Capa finds the mutated Pinbacker in the observation room almost made me shield my eyes and there were a couple other instances where the brilliance overwhelms the screen which fades to white. The first act features very shallow depth of field with close-ups of people's faces and extreme close-ups of their eyes. It helped establish the cramped feel inside Icarus II and did a bit to humanize the characters who were trapped in a technological bubble left to single-mindedly carry out a task. Plus it made the exterior shots all the more expansive. When this shooting style returns very late in the film, it helps bring things full circle as we see Cassie shed tears, Corazon's joy at finding that one seedling had survived a fire, and Pinbacker's madness.
Although Sunshine is scattered thematically, it is a bracing film visually and viscerally. It creates a mood and a tension which creeps inside and stays with you. I noticed things around me in the theatre maybe two times – it held my attention that well. If I have seemed overly harsh on the film this is because I enjoyed it tremendously and just wished that there was a little more to get it over the hump so it could take its place with the greats of the genre.
02 August, 2007
Charlatans on State Street
Last week while wandering State Street I noticed that a new group of charlatans have joined the mountebanks over at Mimosa and opened up a new shop – The Psychic Gallery.

Just look at the prices:

For a mere $35 you can have someone look at your palm and give you a line of bullshit. Madison ought to take a page out of Philadelphia's book and ban fortunetelling "for gain or lucre". I saw nothing indicating that this was just all in good fun or strictly for entertainment purposes which means they're con artists, plain & simple. Just like some of the folks that Mimosa brings in. Check out their events calendar. The Goddess Akeeya will be here later this month to take your time and $95 and then give you a certificate verifying that you received "Seer attunement". Ooooooh! Want a picture of you being attuned for the photo album? No dice: "Please be aware, because of the sacred nature of the information shared, NO videotaping, digital recording, or otherwise allowed." Yes, watching a con artist at work is much too "sacred" to be documented. This charlatan is known at the "female John Edward", with Mr. Edward being a self-proclaimed psychic. He too is fraud, a con, and bullshit artist. These hucksters ought to be driven out of town with brickbats.
Just look at the prices:
For a mere $35 you can have someone look at your palm and give you a line of bullshit. Madison ought to take a page out of Philadelphia's book and ban fortunetelling "for gain or lucre". I saw nothing indicating that this was just all in good fun or strictly for entertainment purposes which means they're con artists, plain & simple. Just like some of the folks that Mimosa brings in. Check out their events calendar. The Goddess Akeeya will be here later this month to take your time and $95 and then give you a certificate verifying that you received "Seer attunement". Ooooooh! Want a picture of you being attuned for the photo album? No dice: "Please be aware, because of the sacred nature of the information shared, NO videotaping, digital recording, or otherwise allowed." Yes, watching a con artist at work is much too "sacred" to be documented. This charlatan is known at the "female John Edward", with Mr. Edward being a self-proclaimed psychic. He too is fraud, a con, and bullshit artist. These hucksters ought to be driven out of town with brickbats.
01 August, 2007
The Great Beer Flood of 1814
I found this over at Pharyngula. Yes, it's the Great Beer Flood of 1814.
On October 16, 1814 the metal hoops that held the big vat together snapped and beer exploded in every direction, causing all the other vats in the building to rupture. A total of 8,500 barrels (1,224,000 liters) of beer smashed through the brick wall of the building and out into the crowded slum area of St. Giles. The sea of beer ran through the streets, flooded basements, and demolished two homes. The wave collapsed a wall in the nearby Tavistock Arms pub and buried a barmaid for three hours. In one home, the beer busted in and drowned a mother and her three-year-old son. A total of eight people were killed, seven due to drowning and one due to alcohol poisoning.
On October 16, 1814 the metal hoops that held the big vat together snapped and beer exploded in every direction, causing all the other vats in the building to rupture. A total of 8,500 barrels (1,224,000 liters) of beer smashed through the brick wall of the building and out into the crowded slum area of St. Giles. The sea of beer ran through the streets, flooded basements, and demolished two homes. The wave collapsed a wall in the nearby Tavistock Arms pub and buried a barmaid for three hours. In one home, the beer busted in and drowned a mother and her three-year-old son. A total of eight people were killed, seven due to drowning and one due to alcohol poisoning.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
